brooke is cool! i want brooke to win! jason has to go he is weird and he has NO TALENT. but carly was a good singer it is just that she had a tatto on her arm!!!!! anybody who calls brooke a horse face is NOT COOL!!!!

Brooke definitely should have gone home. Her vocal range isn't half of what Syesha's is and her constant crying is sickening. The only time she is half way good at all is when she is sitting at a piano. Then she doesn't have to show her extreme uncoordination.

I remember my first summer at Twin Oaks Day Camp I had to perform a skit onstage & I fell down, so I sympathize with what Brooke went through on Idol last night, 4/23!

ACTUALLY, ANONYMOUS 7:38. THIS WAS HER FIRST TIME FORGETTING THE WORDS! THE FIRST TIME SHE STARTED AND STOPPED, WAS BECAUSE SHE HAD THE WRONG NOTE, SHE DID NOT FORGET THE WORDS! ALSO, FYI WHINEY IS SPELLED WHINY! BUT SOMEONE OF YOUR INTELLIGENCE OBVIOUSLY DIDNT KNOW THAT!

She should have pulled a Ashlee Simpson! hahaha

she is a reaaallly good singer!
I dont think they should vote her off just cuz she 4got the lyrics once
she must have been soo nervous!!!!!
I hope they wont count that against her

Ugh. Why would she say she had never done that before when, uh, hello she did it like two weeks ago! She is so fake and I wish she would just be sent home before she butchers another song with her seizure-like performances. Ugh.

Her performance was indeed painful to watch- in fact I haven't enjoyed any of them. Its upsetting that she is still on (and may survive to the next round) and Michael Johns is gone. Votes should be based on talent and not b/c u feel sorry for someone or u think they're cute. If we continue to vote on talent- David Cook will win, but too many of you are captivated by the hokey nonsense of David A and the ah shucks demeanor of Jason. David C shows amazing range and talent- last nights performance solidified that. Hopefully the voters will be smart and he will win top prize.

See ya Horse White....sorry...Brooke White....

no, even tho Brooke had a really bad night and her nerves are shot i believe it will be Jason to go home. ppl will vote to keep her in just like last week cause they know how bad she needed it. i felt uncomfortable for her just like Simon and she's one of my fav's. don't worry all you ppl who don't like her she won't break the top 3 but i'd still buy her cd or download her songs and think she'll do great after the show.

Not sure if she should be eliminated tonight or not. Everyone makes mistakes and she should be judged by her past performances and not because she stopped and started over again, but even the best of them have been voted off the show so I would have to say that she will probably be voted off tonight. Its so sad, she is actually pretty good.
Good luck, Brooke.

bye bye Brooke.