Was Ali Fedotowsky the wrong choice to star in the next installment of The Bachelorette?

Vienna Girardi thinks so.

On Wednesday, Jake Pavelka's final rose recipient shared her opinion with friends on Twitter. The 23-year-old's pick? Gia Allemand.

One of Girardi's Twitter friends, "AliThompson08" raved about third-place Allemand. "she was a sweetheart on the show! she shouldve been the new bachelorette!...not Ali!"

"I can't tell you how much I agree," Girardi replied. Allemand, she says, "would have been the best bachelorette!" Girardi and Fedotowsky famously butted heads on the show. "You don't see the things Vienna said to me. They were very hurtful," Fedotowsky complained on the After the Final Rose special.

Before Fedotowsky was officially named the next Bachelorette, bikini model Allemand, 26, tried to put herself in the running.

"Yeah, I would definitely consider it," she told USA Today in February. "It's such an amazing experience. I would love to find love and see how it is on the other end."

The Ali Fedotowsky season of The Bachelorette begins May 24.