The Dallas-based lawyer, 32, spoke up after cohost Ryan Seacrest read a letter sent in by a fan. "Rachel was clearly in love with Peter," the note read. "Bryan was runner up. She chose him because he was willing to give her a ring…she should have chosen true love over a ring."
Lindsay didn't mince words. "It's so funny to me, I've never been one to settle or to be desperate for anything…that’s why I was 32 and still single. So like, when people say things like that, like Bryan was runner up, I'm like 'no,' I think you can clearly see that I have a lot of love for Bryan," she said. "I never would have just chosen a ring."
During the emotional Bachelorette finale, Lindsay said goodbye to runner-up Peter Kraus in a heartbreaking breakup scene. "I am in love with you. But I don’t feel that I am ready to ask you to marry me, tomorrow. I don’t want to stop being with you," Kraus said at the time. Lindsay replied: "I want you to do it because you want to do it."
Some viewers believe that she said goodbye to him because he wouldn't propose. Kraus reached out following their breakup, but Lindsay had clearly moved on.
"That was a closed chapter for me. My focus was Bryan, I chose Bryan for a reason," Lindsay told Seacrest on Tuesday. "Peter had his chance."
Want stories like these delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter!
For the latest celebrity entertainment, news and lifestyle videos, subscribe to Us Weekly's YouTube Page!