Hewitt and the TRL host met at a 1998 MTV gig and carried on a long-distance courtship -- but the yearlong romance ended badly. When Hewitt appeared on Last Call With Carson Daly in 2005, the two buried the hatchet. "Can we just say that, for the time being, no matter what happened, I was a really good girlfriend to you and you were a great boyfriend?" she asked. "The latter is so true," Daly joked. "The first part is definitely true, but. . ."