After meeting on the set of Glee in 2009, the costars began dating in early 2012
On May 16, 2012 in NYC, Michele and Monteith packed on the PDA during the New York Rangers vs. New Jersey Devils playoff game at Madison Square Garden. "I saw some photos and I was like 'Damn! We look good,' " Michele told E! News of how their Glee sex scene turned out. "As a fan of the show, it's something I wanted to see for awhile and it's very interesting how everything plays out."