Are Jessica Simpson and Mischa Barton under arrest for crimes against fashion? recently hit the streets of midtown Manhattan to cull opinions on recent outfits worn by Simpson, 29, and Barton, 24.

While some passersby praised Simpson's "pretty," bright peach ensemble, others wondered if her cleavage was too pronounced. One critic sniped that the "fluffy sleeves" make the star look "bigger than she is."

As for Barton's outfit? "She looks pregnant," says one fashion cop. "Like she got out of bed," quips another.

Agree or disagree? Watch the video now (above)!