Would You Rock Extreme Eyeliner Like Katharine McPhee?

Winged eyeliner continues to be one of Hollywood's hottest makeup trends, with stars like Lauren Conrad proving that the look is both edgy and completely wearable, plus a fail-proof way to enhance your eye shape.

And while most celebrity makeup artists advise to draw the cat-eye lines just slightly beyond the outer corner of your eyes, Katharine McPhee turned up the drama with one-inch wings at the New Balance Experience Store opening in NYC Aug. 10.

PHOTOS: How to prevent a summer makeup meltdown

The American Idol season five runner-up sported the extreme look along with heavy black lines on her top lids.

McPhee, 27, is no stranger to trying out bold beauty looks. In 2009, the natural brunette chopped her hair into a shaggy pixie cut and dyed it platinum blonde.

Tell Us: Do you think McPhee's eyeliner is flattering or too much?

What Do You Think of Katharine McPhee's Eyeliner?


What Do You Think of Katharine McPhee's Eyeliner?

It's cute, edgy and on-trend. I would try it.
It's way too over-the-top. I would never wear it.
890 Total Votes