A Threesome With Jon Hamm and Billy Eichner? Find Out Who Turned Them Down

A Threesome With Jon Hamm and Billy Eichner? Find Out Who Turned Them Down

1, 2, 3! Billy Eichner and Jon Hamm scour the streets of New York City searching for women and men to have a threesome with in a preview for the Tuesday, November 15, season 5 premiere of Billy on the Street.

In the clip above, Eichner, 38, and the handsome Mad Men alum, 45, approach random strangers and offer them $1 if they agree to an impromptu ménage à trois.

“In an attempt to stay current and stay ahead of some inevitable pseudo-highbrow HBO series about living as a threesome,” the comedian-actor jokingly says at the beginning of the video, “I’m about to hit the street with Emmy Award–winner Jonathan Hamm to play a new game I like to call ‘Would You Have a Threesome With Me and Jon Hamm?’”

When the good-looking duo begin approaching pedestrians, asking if they’d be willing to participate in a threesome, several women immediately turn them down because they’re married. However, it only takes the tiniest push to finally persuade one of the ladies. “[Your husband] would want you to have a threesome with the star of Mad Men!” Eichner persists. “I know he doesn’t have great buzz at the moment, but he’s still a handsome fella.”

Adds Hamm: “I used to! Imagine that it was 2009.”

“Yes, a threesome with 2016 Billy Eichner, but 2009 Jon Hamm! Yes?” Eichner coaxes, to which the woman concedes: “OK!”

Though they had to really coerce the women of Manhattan to say yes, Eichner and Hamm had a much easier time with the guys they spoke to. “I would totally do that!” says one man, while another enthuses: “Sure why not? Sounds like a great time.”

To see how many people actually accepted Eichner and Hamm’s invitation — and who had no idea who they were — watch the hilarious clip below.

Season 5 of Billy on the Street premieres on TruTV, Tuesday at 10:30 p.m ET.

Can't get enough of Us? Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter packed with the latest celeb news, hot pics and more!