Is Haley Reinhart the Next American Idol?

Entertainment May. 5, 2011 AT 11:10AM
Yes - she's amazing!
47% 3962
No -- I've seen better.
53% 4407

As American Idol's Randy Jackson vehemently proclaimed on Wednesday's performance show, the remaining five contestants are "in it to win it."

And while the five -- Lauren Alaina, Scotty McCreery, James Durbin and Jacob Lusk (though not so much) -- delivered strong performances, no one's drive was more evident than Haley Reinhart.

MORE IDOL: Enter to win a trip to see the finale live in L.A.!

For Idol's 'Then and Now' theme week -- where contestants sang one current hit and one from the 1960s, Reinhart, 20, opted to belt an unreleased Lady Gaga track, "You and Me," for her first outing.

Judge Jennifer Lopez praised her routine, but wondered if the audience would connect with an unfamiliar track, which Gaga gave her blessing to Reinhart to sing. Randy Jackson agreed with Lopez, telling Reinhart that the song didn't do her any favors.

PHOTOS: See Haley's Idol competition

Steven Tyler, on the other hand, had a feeling Reinhart was stepping up her game.

"I think you're just one perfect song away from being the American Idol," he told her.

Arguably, that song was Reinhart's second of the night, "House of the Rising Sun." Delivering a "quintessential Haley" performance, Reinhart had the judges singing a different tune.

VIDEO: Idol's Steven Tyler dishes on songwriting sessions with Johnny Depp

"You blossomed," enthused Jackson. Added Tyler: "Sweet and sour, raspy; I can really relate to that and that really sells a song. You sold everybody tonight."

As the top five become the top four Thursday, tell Us: Does Haley have what it takes to become season 10's American Idol?

By Allison Corneau for For more Channel Surfing, click here.

comments powered by Disqus