Former Bachelorette star DeAnna Pappas knows how Jillian (here, with Wes, Ed, Reid and Kiptytn) must have felt narrowing down her final choices. "You're extremely nervous," Pappas says, recalling her own experience. "The final four [guys], you have really strong feelings for. So I know for me going back and seeing Graham and Jeremy on my season, it was extremely hard, so I know it's going to be that way for Jillian."