hahahahaha

Katherine Mcphee has talent & real natural beauty. She looks like a young Jacqueline Smith. They should remake the "Wizzard of Oz" and cast her in the Judy Garland part. I can't get her redition of "Over the Rainbow" out of my head. At least they should make a new recording of this old song & bring some good music back to the music world. She has everything a star should have. I think most women are jealous of anyone who is prettier than they are. How anyone can say she is fat is crazy or needs glasses. It just jealousy.

Unfortunately this is a generation that feels young women should be reed thin to look nice. Marilyn Monroe was thought to have a beautiful body, but now would be called "fat." As some of you pointed out, Katherine McFee has a beautiful body, healthy and curvacious. I was stunned to hear some of you say she needed to lose weight. She has no weight problem that I can see. I would be very disappointed to see her become skinny.

Paris, was an awesome singer with a unique and fresh voice and excellent showmanship. Who cares what she sounds like when she talks. Everyone always has to have an opinion about the way someone looks, how they talk, how they dress, the way they wear their hair, when noone is perfect and each and everyone of us has a flaw of some kind. She should not have been voted off at all. Katherine is beautiful and she is a great singer as well, but Katherine needs work. Everytime she sings she oversings her songs when she doesn't have to or need to. This is the same comment that the judges give her, and Katherine is not good at taking criticism either. I hope that if she wins, she takes in to consideration what the judges have told her throughout the competition and try to apply it, because for me, she doesn't measure up to a Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood.

thank you FIRST TIME SEEING IDOL

define textbook case plz.

Because you're a textbook case. It's what makes blogging with you so funny.

********LOLA SLIDES DOWN THE WALL AND CURLS UP INTO THE FETAL POSITION WHILE CRADLING A HALF EMPTY BOTTLE OF JACK WITH A HAND FULL OF HER "PRESCRIPTION" HAPPY PILLS WHILE SOFTLY SINGING HERSELF A LULLABY AND ESTIMATING THE LAST TIME SHE TOOK HER TRIM SPA*******

i'm know i'm right...thank you very much! why are yo so rude?!?!? this whole thing wasn't mean until you came into the picture, so just STOP IT ALREADY!!!!! o, and i don't care that other people have a different opinion than mine, i just wanted to share mine like they shared theirs. and i'm not super sensitive!

i am not fat!!! ur mean!!! this whole thing started out with a stupid thing about some fat person, so let's just end it now! i'm not giving up, i just think it's stupid to be fighting about one paragraph that was written. and sarah johnson...can't u read?!?!?!?!back to ian j.:i don't think ur funny, so stop trying to be. o, and i suppose u'll stick up for miss sarah johnson, like u explained everything to her.

Oh was responding to "Lola" who freaked out on me because I agreed with the person named "And The Winner is" who posted that Katherine will need to lose a couple of pounds or the "biz" will make her feel bad about herself. She freaked all out on me so I responded to her and the site removed both of our last posts to each other :) I thought this a place to put your opinion and she got all extra sensitive and offended so I figured she must be a little "plump" herself to have taken it so personal : ) Nothing wrong with a slightly "plump" chick. I date them too sometimes....It just doesn't normally help a girl who is actually trying to be on the side of the biz that Katherine McFee is. That's all.

....OKAY LOLA...IT'S ALRIGHT...IT'S OKAY...CALM DOWN...POP ANOTHER PAXEL BABY! IT'S JUST THE WEIGHT OF SOMEONE YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW THAT WE ARE DISCUSSING HERE...DID WE SKIP OUR MEDS TODAY? IT'S NOT THAT SERIOUS....TRY BEING THAT PASSIONATE ABOUT SOME REAL ISSUE THE WORLD IS FACING LIKE ABUSE OF CHILDREN, STARVATION, OR THE WAR IN IRAQ.HA HA
AN AMERICAN IDOL KID BEING A BIT "THICKER" THEN THE BUSINESS CALLS FOR IS HARDLY A REASON TO GET ALL CRAZY....ACTUALLY I THINK I GET IT NOW...YOU ARE HUSKY CHICK YOURSELF...OKAY...MY BAD....I GET IT...HUSKY IS OKAY...THERE IS THAT BETTER? HA HA HA

ShortyK is so wrong!

i don't care what u say, ian j. but she does not need 2 lose weight. just get over yourself being such a problem solver and help us all. and i only said she was fat because other poeple did and i needed to defend her

I think paris is good but not that good and my vote will be elliot, and its been like that since day one but if there happens to be a second guest i would go with chris.