E-MAIL
IM
DIGG THIS
FACEBOOK...or ex-boyfriends of Simon's. And she's classy enough to have undergarments that match the outfit -- if she weren't wearing undergarments, there would be comments about that -- if she were wearing a different dress, there would be comments about that -- if she were wearing some other shoes, there would be comments about that. This young lady is well on her way to some great things -- she's much further along than Idol folk. In this case, Idol's loss is America's gain. Isn't it great that everyone can have an opinion and share it with the world?
Idol Update: Simon Gets His Nasty Back!
Wednesday February 14, 2007
ROBYN TROUP
FilmMagic.com
Wednesday February 14, 2007
FilmMagic.com
Following four (mostly) painful weeks of watching starry-eyed singers warble their renditions of “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” and “Amazing Grace” for Simon, Randy and Paula, American Idol’s Hollywood round finally began last night. But don’t for a minute think that the peanut gallery was kind to our Hollywood kids, because frankly, last night’s semi-final kickoff was a bloodbath.
By the end of two audition days, a majority of the 172 singers who stepped onstage at L.A.’s Orpheum Theater were sent packing with a curt goodbye from Randy, who simply stated “It’s the end of the road.”
Fan faves Baylie Brown, Matt Sato and Jarrod Fowler all had strong Day One showings, but fell apart during the make-or-break second day’s group auditions.
A nasty-as-he-wants-to-be Simon and Co. continued to crush contestants’ dreams, leaving one to wonder who exactly will make tonight’s Top 24 cut if belters like Ashlyn Carr and Jory Steinberg were shown the door. Eagle-eyed viewers may have even spotted Texas teen Robyn Troup, who brought “SexyBack” to the Grammy stage with Justin Timberlake, getting cut after a painful group performance.
However, the night’s highlight was most certainly the group performance by the all-male quartet of Chris Sligh, Thomas Lowe, Rudy Cardenas and beatboxer Blake Lewis, who wowed the judges with an impressive and expressive version of “How Deep Is Your Love.” These boys have got the looks, talent and personality to make it through, but time will tell if their song stylings will merit a top 24 finish. Idol wraps its Hollywood round tonight, but for now, the fellas earned our Usmagazine.com “Pick of the Week” award.
Talk to Us: Which kicked-out contestant deserved a second shot during Hollywood week?
|
Posted by Allison Corneau at 9:29 am ET
19 Comments
4:35 PM
makaschild Says:
1:54 AM
Anonymous Says:
Hey she beautiful!!!!and can sing and whosever writing ugly notes must be jealous x-girlfriends of Justins
10:54 PM
Anonymous Says:
well good for her she has a dream and she went for it she did okay for to say it was her first time.
9:34 AM
girlgirlATL Says:
The 2007 Grammy Show was a good one. Kanye, could have worked a more traditional dress code, I certainly agree, but if he wants to look like he's all about the "hood" that is certainly his choice. Chris Brown is a good performer, he's young and will only get better. I'd rather see him than a rapper who's talent consists of holding up his pants and screaming vulgarities, and berating women. I will never undersatnd the Justin Timberlake Hype. That is mediocre talent! I don't even see the potential there. Christina Agulerra was excellent, we can certainly use more talent of that caliber and last but not least congratulations to a much deserving and most humble Mary J. Blige.
8:23 PM
love, love me too Says:
I love you Simon
oh yes I do
I don't love anybody
like I love you
When you're not near to me
I'm blue
Oh Simon
I love you
Happy Valentine's Day big boy
8:13 PM
Kate Says:
Is that her underwear showing??? How tacky!!! No one said anything when she dressed??? And 4:29, get over it. Remember Fantasia??!!!
5:27 PM
Ava Says:
But that's just it - Robyn has an ok voice, but compared to other people, she's not unique. There's nothing about that girl that stands out as a star. She wasn't cut because of her race, so please, don't start that. I'm so sick of every other thread on here being about that because it's so OT. Back to my point - she's an average singer and American Idol isn't looking for average. They're trying to make money and to do that, they need powerhouse vocalists with the personality to match (i.e. Fantasia Barrino). Personally, I think Africa Miranda should've been the one to perform with Justin, but whatever. Now THAT'S a talented girl who would've made it on Idol.
4:29 PM
Anonymous Says:
I think Robyn was cut because she is a pretty African American girl with talent. It seems to me that American Idol tend to shy away from them. They are okay with putting the Mandisa's onstage with the powerhouse voice but not so "Hollywood" body because there is no danger of catching a real following. Just my opinion. I used to like American Idol a lot, but now I feel like winners and finalist are picked by producers and for ratings.
3:35 PM
Ava Says:
I think Simon is right 90% of the time and he was DEFINITELY right about that Robyn Troupe girl. Her performance with Justin at the Grammy's was subpar at best - I was NOT impressed! They could've used that four minutes or so to let somebody else sing.
3:02 PM
CindiCat Says:
Dang Post 2:57.....don't hold back, tell us how you REALLY felt about the Grammy show!!
I thought it was a good show and I enjoyed it. Just my opinion.
3:00 PM
CindiCat Says:
I agree with 12:03 post.....I must add that what he says, 99% of the "viewer's" are hollering the same thing or worse, AT their TV!! Me included.
To post 2:12....at least she is WEARING undergarments!! ;)
2:57 PM
Brit Says:
I think that whole performance really trashed out the Grammy's... The Grammy's are suppossed to be classy, and about the artist. Stupid Rappers and Justin Timberlake ruined everything. What happened to real music. DID YOU SEE KANYE WEST COME OUT ON STAGE TO PRESENT IN HIS HOOD???!!!! what a loser, he thinks hes so great. And dont even get me started on Chris brown, hes just as talentless as all the other wannabee gangstas. SO WHY IS HE NOMINATED????? And then there was the whole Carrie underwood thing. Kelly Clarkson is the only one that American Idol helped, and Carrie should just go die!
2:12 PM
Anonymous Says:
It is Robyn Troup who sang with Justin Timberlake at the Grammy's. She did a great job I thought, although people's reaction to the idea of fans voting who they want to sing with JT wasn't favorable. I thought it was cool, except for the camera in their face with all of them posing holding hands all the time. She should have chosen a different dress or different undergarments.
1:39 PM
Anonymiss Says:
I think Simon is right 99.999% of the time. He's the only judge that tells it like it is and I love him for it!
1:24 PM
Anonymous Says:
Well Simon discovered Leona Lewis in the UK. She will rock my world when she hits the States. You will all see what I mean. She is brilliant, sweet and oh so talented.
1:13 PM
Anonymous Says:
This gal rocked it out out at the Grammy's with JT. Go on girl...do your thang:-)
1:08 PM
Anonymous Says:
Who's the girl in the picture above?
1:02 PM
Anonymous Says:
I completely agree!!! i'm so sick of people getting pissed off at the judges (Simon in particular) because they are "mean"... gimme a break people! this is a singing COMPETITION!!! These people think they're entitled to something... there are SO many entertainers and singers out there... competition is fierce and the show is looking for the BEST... THE BEST>... THE BEST... not just the ok's...
12:03 PM
R Woman Says:
Simon is right 99% of the time with what he says. And Yes, he knows exactly what he's talking about when he says someone "has it" and someone doesn't. As far as being rude and insensative, what is he suppose to do, sit down for an hour with each person and have a therapy session?
