i have seen the video and you could tell who is who at all times. In the dance part, they used Shakira hips for one move. Shakira had on this chain on her clothes and they kept switching them from front to back. Beyonce maybe able to move but she cannot shake like Shakira.

What are you people insane? Beyonce has it going on in all departments and yes, you all know this, and if you don't agree you are down right hating because shakira don't even come close. shakira I never really heard of her until i saw beyonce video and yes shakira is ok, but she is no beyonce. so B please don't fall for that fake a-- hollywood stuff, because look and them now, trying to get fake a-- boobs, lips butt implants tanning ect.. what a double standard, be yourself like Beyonce she is so beautiful and hot. All you haters that's a sickness go get help. All the stuff that I mention about you all getting fake stuff added esp butt implants and lips implants deny that to ok.

Beyonce wishes she looks like Shakira with the killing abs, instead she has fat all over. B is fake, fake, fake. She thinks she has the biggest butt in Hollywood, she needs to wake up. Jeniffer Lopez has the biggest butt, she sticks her butt up in every picture and on the red carpet. Shes over the top. Shakira doesnt wear a lot of makeup, shes natural and beautiful. B wears a lot, she looks lke shi* without it on, even her bff Tyra Banks. She thinks shes #1, wake up hoe, ur last years news.
LOVE YA SHKAIRA!!<<<3333

Beyonce's B'day got pulled from the shelf, stupid b*tch!

This skank deserves to burn in Hell! Des'ree rightfully sued this skank's a*8 for covering her song without her permission and re-titling it.

Beyonce is a fraud, a fake, a phony!

Also, a hypocrite who is all that cos she is dating Jay-Z!

I Think Beyonce Is a Great Person She's Sweet And She Has Lots Of Talent She Can sing Dance and Act Shakira I Feel The Same Way About But Be serious Half The Time shakira Sounds Like A Man When She Sings But She Sure Can Move

Dear Beyoncé, Shakira is the beautiful one with talent. There, now you can tell the two of you apart.

as far as i know you hear more about beyonce than shakira, so i would think shakira is trying to be like beyonce. in the pic shakiras hair is out of whack and beyonce has control of hers.

I like them both but I have seen B in person and although she is a beautiful girl they use special effects to slim her down for photos and videos.

Both ladies are pretty, talented and RICH. Go Beyonce anyone who thinks your not an attractive woman (girlfriend) are true haters. GO TEXAS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Beyonce should not speak. She and Shakira are not even built the same. Beyonce is last months news. She's inarticulate and never comes across as being bright.

To all my mami's keepin it real:
I'm glad someone (Beyoncé) has not fallen for hollywood's idea of beauty.... skin-n-bones! I'm a HUGE Shakira fan, have been since long before she crossed over. But Beyoncé has her beat in the body department! Shakira has killer abs, but B has it going on all over! Thank you, B (& Tyra), for showing us that you don't have to be skin-n-bones (ANTM, Nichole Richie, Paris Hilton, need I go on?) to be K linda y bonita!!!! Gracias Mamí!

Shakira looks 1000 times better than Beyonce do.Byonce WHOOO?

B is HOTT, Shakira is HOTT, they are both beautiful and talented and I'd lke to meet both them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

come on, doesnt it seem like beyonce is trying to hard to be like shakira, she just mad because she can not move like her, just like that stupid music video deja vu, all that crazy dancing was stupid. I like the girl beyonce say cool, but she needs to be herself not try to be like other people. why else would she do the video with shakira, she just wants to show the world that she can try and dance like shakira. their both great singers and dancers in their own way.