I think, they look fine. Not too thin.
Though, I also think they need to be left alone. If they do have eating disorders they do not need millions of people pointing out they might do and all these things about there weight. Eating disorders, anyhow, are not something people like to brag about, so all this attention on the possibility is likely to effective them so much either way.
I will say though, it's taken them alot to become that thin and maintain it for so long. Probably have sacrified alot too.

This is wrong people shouldnt look like this it's wrong if you can see their ribs. Why would you want kids or any young person to try to look like this? Miley Cyrus, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato, The Jonas Brothers, They can be looked up too.
Being too skinny isn't too pretty. It's wrong to show these kind of people to younger kids and Teenagers is just putting the idea of being a size 0 is what they need to do. I'm 17 and 125 pounds, and guess what? haha I don't care. People call me fat, but I don't care. I know I am not fat at all.
I'm happy being myself and nothing else. Teenage girls would die to look like that, and it needs to stop. Hollywood needs to change the way the choose their actors and actresses. They are all setting a bad ex for girls at a young age.
So do us all a favor and help your actors and actresses eat more.

Im from the UK too, i just watched the first episode and im sorry but 'annie' is far too thin. I agree people should look how they want, however, she obviously has a problem, shes a beautiful girl, but her body is unhealthy. For godsake her collarbone pretrudes from her body! I have never been worried enough to actually checkup and make sure people have taken notice and are trying to get somebody help. For everybody sticking up for her, yes shes beautiful but shes ILL dont sugercoat it.

well, blame the media for this, they are always like this girl is too thin and then when they gain weight they are like this girl is too fat, and you know I'm right, don't blame these girls because celebrity and everyday girls are always being criticized for being too fat or thin (I was critized at school for being too fat and I weighed 52kg and Im 164cm tall)

i think they look fantastic. they shoudl be allowed to look how they want. no one makes fat unhealthy TV stars lose weight, why are they any different?

WELL.
im 5'4.5 and i weighed 92 pounds for a bit. my bmi was 15.5
yes, i wasnt eating.

shenae grimes bmi is 15.9
for her build, i think she looks okay.

jessica stroups bmi is 15.2
shes on the border of too skinny in that picture.
and to be honest, if you see more recent pictures of jessica its obvious that shes gained at least 5 pounds.

Watch the first episode of Tru Blood on HBO which was filmed in the spring. Jessica plays the "Sorority Girl" shown at the very beginning. If you think she's not too thin, look what she looked like only 4-5 months ago. It's tragic how much weight she's lost. She was actually pretty then...now, not so much.

Who do you think would win in a fight between Hayden Pantiere and Jessica Stroup?.

I don't think that Jessica or Shenae are too thin! They're perfectly normal weight. I have to say I agree with Shannen about what she said in her interview on Ryan Seacrest's show that they're not too thin and besides like Shannen said...they eat on set. They don't barf anything up...they eat it...that's what Shannen said. And people should stop ratting on Shannen too! Not everything about her "wild bad self" is true, she's not overly wild. Maybe she might have been when she was younger and for good reason...she was in the limelight all through her teenage years. Its the same thing that has happened to Daniel Radcliffe(Harry Potter)...he's grown up in the limelight since the movies and so what if he had sex and lost his virginity to his hairdresser or make-up artist! Sheesh people....you all should just quit digging in celebrities lives..they're people too ya know! The Papparazzi all suck and yeah! I hate Papparazzi! Also, one last thing, people should have a little more heart when it comes to Shannen and everything! Judge yourself before you judge others...I bet there's other people out there who have gotten a DUI who still say pick on Shannen. I also bet she's not the only one who gets drunk....loads of people get drunk everyday and noone picks on them about it...only celebrities. Sheesh!

I think that Grimes looks ok for now...at least she has a bit of muscle tone for christ's sake. The other one is a bit to thin. I am 5'2 108. I look normal for how short I am. I work out and eat healthy...and that is how much I weigh as a result. nothing more, nothing less. I think the idea here is to try not to worry too much, the fact that they are on this cover will probably make them re-assess their eating habits. I think people are being a little too harsh. There are tons of women in hollywood that look like this. It is a whole other planet as far as I am concerned. Young girls are getting the wrong message though, I am a teacher and the things that come out of teen girls mouths is astonishing as of late....they count calories! It is a scary message, but should be taken with a grain of salt.

These girls are too skinny by medical standards; at the weights they are estimated at, they are underweight. I know that many people are concerned about the obesity epidemic, and that is a cause for concern, but so are eating disorders. I am not saying that these girls do have eating disorders (though I would bet that they do), but they are role models for young girls. If these girls do have eating disorders or some other reason for being underweight, I think it's great that the show is addressing it. It's not healthy for them or for kids to see.

A lot of people on here have been saying that they look great. It unfortunate that as a society, out idea of beauty has become so warped that even emaciation is seen as beauty by so many. Being underweight or restricting what you eat can cause heart problems, osteoporosis, and death. We think that is beautiful? We need to stop that view, because I do not want kids growing up thinking that's what they need to look like.

If these girls do have eating disorders (or drug addictions, ect), they need medical care and therapy. Eating disorders are very hard to recover from; it's not as easy as just eating more. For anorexics, food is something they are phobic of, and it takes work to undo that. So, I am glad that someone is intervening.

THEY LOOKS DISGUSTING! Sorry, but modern cameras does NOT add 10 pounds anymore! Yet and still they are nasty looking! But it's great to see the media not showering them with compliments on their weight!

well look at samantha ronson...shes ridiculously thin as well but no one pays attention because shes not wearing little dresses daily. maybe we should stop saying that people who look too perfect for their own good have eating disorders. they may and they may not, but there are other people out there that have that body type just pay attention. or now because i've brought sam ronson to your attention are we all going to accuse her of being yet another anorexic girl in hollywood

Ok seriously they're too thin. Especially Jessica Stroup. I struggled with an eating disorder(bulimia) for two years and I weighed 92lbs at 5"1 (not really THAT skinny honestly) but I look at these girls and freak out. I know anorexics who were "fatter" than them. I'm not saying they should 'eat a burger' but they should be more responsible. So many young kids watch this and they see these teenagers who look so alarmingly thin and think 'that's whats attractive?' ok I should look like that and maybe not develop eating disorders but definately bad eating habits.

I hope they put on weight. I prefer the GG girls. Leighton, Jessica and Blake are gorgeous! Jenny is on the very thin side but she's prepubescent and god...if she stood next to them she'd look fat!

I TOTALLY AGRRE THAT THIS GIRLS ARE TOO SKINNY, JUST WATCH THE MOVIE PROM NIGTH, IN WICH JESSICA STROUP ACTS AND SHE IS DEFINITELY SKINNIER NOW, AND THAT IT´S NOT HEALTHY.
I AM A FAN OF THE ORIGINAL 90210 AND JUST THE COMPARISSION IS SCARING,THE GIRLS FROM THAT SHOW LOOK HEALTHY NOT THE NEW ONES, AND MY POINT IS THAT THIS SHOW IS BEING WATCHED BY MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF TEENAGERS FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD( I AM FROM SPAIN)AND THEY ARE SENDING A BAD EXAMPLE.
I AGREE THAT OBESITY IS A MAJOR CAUSE OF MORBIMORTALITY IN USA, BUT BELIEVE ME THAT ANOREXIA AND DEPRESSION DUE TO LOW SELF ESTIME BECAUSE YOU CANT FIT THE STANDARDS OF SOCIETY IS AS BAD ALSO.