Tonight he told Haley to continue wearing less clothing its her only saving grace.
It was uncalled for and SEXIST.

Every week her dresses / shorts get shorter and shorter...
it was only a matter of time before someone said something...

"babyface," you white trash idiot, roll over and go f*ck your cousin. because your ignorant opinions aren't worth writing down, you f*cking retard.

Paula said simon has a neddle @ick. Oh well @otherbleeper to bad you aint black.

I'm in the mood for love...only if it's with Simon Cowell. Simon just makes me howel when I'm in the mood for love. I love you Simon.

She does have great legs. If she didn't want people looking at them..she wouldn't be wearing such short dresses!

My boyfriend made the comment that she has great legs too - so what? They are men, for christ sake! And by the way, coming from a female, she DOES have awesome legs. If I had legs that looked like that I'd be flaunting them too.

Who cares if he is sexist. SIMON IS SEXY.

I agree with most comments Simon makes about the contestants. He's rude and harsh on poor performances but this is the type of rejection that singers, actors, or entertainers are subjected to in auditions. They need to get use to it. Paula and Randy are nice and go out of their way to be positive. It's a nice balance. Haley uses her sexuality and seems upset when she gets called on it. The woman can sing. She needs to learn how to use her vocals and perform instead of just singing into the microphone. I agree with Simon, she does have nice legs.

The reason he said "You have great legs" is because that was his way of saying that's the only thing good about her performance. And yeah...she is SO annoying how she wears skirts up to her "whatever" and then is offended when they say something. She should be thankful she has been around this long, because she doesn't deserve to be. You can tell every wk that she knows it should be her. And if she doesn't know it, she's insane. Simon was just speaking the truth for yet another wk again....the singing is not what's great about her performances.

Simon IS American Idol, just like he was on the original Pop Idol. There is a reason he is there..and that is that he is usually 100% right. People just need to get passed who they want to win, and you will see/hear that he is usually dead on in his crtique. Haley is not a great singer, but she does have fabulous legs. Get this girl a NAIR commercial or a shoe contract

Haley did a good job this week. The judges acted very unprofessional. All of them.

Simon is the epitomy of 'what a man is...what a man should be'...he just does it for me. Wish he'd do it to me. I love this man. I go to sleep thinking about him at night. He is all that and a whole bunch more.

If Simon had told one of the guys he had great legs, he'd be considered gay. Simon tells a girl that, and he's sexist. And he had to say SOMETHING, he obviously was trying to avoid commenting on the quality of Haley's singing. The guy can't win.

i value simons opinion over the 2 dumbazz, fake judges. the truth hurts!