Mariah is so great. Oh sexy, pretty and sexy. I remembered I've seen her at the celeb club "million airecupid" c o m a few weeks ago. She exclaimed she is looking for a great man for serious relationship there.

I love a lot of Mariah Carey's songs, but watching her perform drives me crazy!! Nothing about her looks natural. She always looks so stiff and everything looks forced. She never stops moving her hands but her feet seem to be planted to the stage. I wish she would relax, dress more age-appropriate and just sing.

I don't really have a favorite Mariah Carey song, I like whatever I've heard from her!

BIG thing going around is..........american idol stars kristy lee cook and david archuletah have a THING going on. this has been talked about all over the place. weird because she's older than him but nothing would surprise me. all the david archuletah fans aren't happy about this ESPECIALLY the girls.

another thing going around is kristy lee cook NEVER sold her horse. this was a story used as a sympathy ploy so people would like her and keep her on the show. she has tons of horses *she lives on a ranch* and out of all the horses she sells hers? she has money by the way. her parents are NOT broke. kristy's whole family lives quite well. lets just say they're rich. cat got out of the bag that kristy prepares herself to be in the bottom 3 but she knows she'll be okay. she's quite smug. she knows her brother in-law has a lot of friends and they vote a lot. she's totally syked about this website called vote for the worst. they vote for the worst contestants. she knows if a following follows what they say she'll stay on forever. she's so confident that she actually thinks she's going to win american idol. just ask around. visit the website. you'll see. just some information for all your american idol lovers.

I think tonights Idol is going to be bad. I don't see any of these girls able to pull off her music, and well, I'm not too sure about the boys either. Mariah is in a league of her own with her music, just like Whitney Houston is, and all the other great powerful singers of yester-year and of today. Like someone else said, the contestants better be able to make up for all those high notes Mariah does. NONE of those kids can hit those notes like Mariah can.

Syesha will not stand out tonight, because she tries to be like a Whitney Houston or a Mariah Carey. Brooke is so boring. KLC just plain stinks. Carly will try to belt out a song, and she won't succeed, because she's a wannabe herself. David A. is BORING everyweek and he's too Disney. Maybe him and Miley can hook up. I like Jason, but we shall see if he's versatile and doesn't become predicatable and boring with song choices. David Cook is by far the best in the competition. I'm curious to see how he's going to rock out a Mariah Carey song. About the plagiarizing comment, oh whatever, what do you think Idol is about? They cover other people's songs. All that drama that surrounded DC was just a bunch of hoopla.

Please stop complaining about Michael Johns. He wasn't the best in the competition. A lot of people who voted for him voted based on looks. Just look at what people type or listen to them when they comment about Michael Johns....."Oh my gosh! There's no more eye candy on the show!" Michael Johns wouldn't be able to touch Chris Daughtry neither. Daughtry is untouchable. Michael would never be as successful as Daughtry, and Michael certainly doesn't have the talent Daughtry has. I would guess though, all the girls that wanna do the kissy face with Michael will buy his album (that's if he can find a record lable) because he's "so cuuuuuute! like OMGosh!"

I bummed that Micheal Johns is gone, but will still watch for Carly to WIN

well, syesha should do good.

LOL! 12:42 PM, you took the words right out of my mouth! I cannot stand all of the diva posing. Victoria/Posh is the queen of awkward poses. I still think Mariah is a fabulous singer. You go girl!

I love her voice, but she is such a FAKE!!!! I look forward to hearing the songs that they choose and what they do with them.

Mariah is a has been.

funny how everyone thought this would the the guys' season and turns out there's now more girls than guys left. even though I'm sure it will come down to the two David's in the finals.

just saying.

Michael John's has star quality, and was really the only person I cared to hear on that show. 99.9% of them do not have that kind of charisma. Now, that he is gone, I don't bother watching it.

As for Mariah Carey, I stopped listening to her years ago. She is my age, and I outgrew her, and her pop music.

Good thing A&E has tons of CSI reruns :)

It's well known that Mariah only likes to be photographed fron the right side. And she's always posing and hamming it up for the cam.

I quit watching after my favorite, Michael was cut. So have all of my friends and family. We loved him.