Hasselbeck and O’Donnell had disagreed over politics throughout the ABC talk show’s 10th season, but their conflict turned into a shouting match in May 2007 when O’Donnell accused the Survivor alum of not defending her against media pundits who interpreted O’Donnell’s anti-war criticisms as equating the U.S. troops to terrorists.
“Every day since September, I have told you that I support the troops,” the SMILF actress told her costar. “I asked you if you believed what the Republican pundits were saying. You said nothing, and that’s cowardly.”
Hasselbeck responded: “I just don’t understand why it’s my fault if people spin words that you put out there or phrases that suggest things. And I gave you an opportunity two days ago to clarify the statement that got you in trouble on all those things.”
After the argument, speculation mounted that O’Donnell would exit her original run on the show early, even though she was only a month away from her previously announced departure. On her blog, the Emmy winner seemed to confirm the speculation in a poem, writing: “It may be time to be done / endings r hard 4 all / emotions r high / talking is tough.”
Two days after the fight, ABC announced that O’Donnell had asked to be released from her contract. But her first abrupt exit was far from the end of her cold war with Hasselbeck.
The Fox & Friends alum eventually left The View in 2013 but returned nearly nine years later as a guest cohost.
“So much fun having @elisabethhasselbeck back at the #HotTopics table with us to guest co-host as part of our historic 25th season celebration! 💕,” the show captioned an August 2022 Instagram snap of Hasselbeck on set.
Upon Hasselbeck’s return to the show, O’Donnell opened up old wounds and shared her thoughts about the new guest panelist. “I watched it, from yesterday,” the A League of Their Own actress said in a TikTok video at the time. “And I remembered why I don’t want to watch it with her anymore. Her little Post-it notes. I don’t know.”
She added: “Listen. It’s strange. Yeah. Um, hope you’re having a good day. And if you saw that yesterday, hope you recovered.”
Scroll down to read more about their continuing feud: