"We're going head to head in the classic drinking game: flip cup," an excited Fallon, 39, told the crowd. "Instead of teams, we'll be doing all the drinking and flipping ourselves… First to chug the beer and flip all the cups over, wins."
The supermodel, 31, revealed: "I mean, I've never played this game before. She then asked the crowd: "Whose bets are on whom?" The audience appeared to favor "Jimmy," who recently played a botched game of beer pong against Diane Keaton.
Watch the nail-biting competition between Fallon and Kerr above to see who won!
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!