From 2005 to 2007, Seyfried was in a serious relationship with the musician/actor. "He was amazing but the problem was that I fell in love with him too early," the In Time star told The Daily Mail. "He was so special and being with him had such a profound effect on me, but the timing wasn't right. He's a low-key guy and I was entering into this world of celebrity which he hates and which scares him. I didn't want him to be unhappy or have to deal with it, and so it was me who ended it."