American Idol's Most Shocking Eliminations Ever!

Pia Toscano

Season 10's frontrunner had never appeared in the bottom three before her April 7 elimination. "I'm shocked. I'm angry. I don't know what to say," Toscano's staunchest supporter, judge Jennifer Lopez, said after the announcement, struggling to hold back tears.

ADVERTISEMENT

Inside Us Weekly

comments powered by Disqus