Bachelor Nation’s Cassie Randolph is thinking about her next chapter after marrying Brighton Reinhardt.
“Deciding whether to sip my way through the holidays or get pregnant,” Randolph, 31, wrote over a Tuesday, September 29, TikTok video, which she captioned, “Decisions decisions.”
In the clip, Randolph took a sip out of a glass as she filmed herself and lifted her hands to create an invisible baby bump. After pretending to cradle a baby, Randolph’s eyes got wide as she leaned into the camera and took another sip.
Randolph’s husband weighed in in the comments section, writing, “Both options scare me.”
The Bachelor alum and Reinhardt, 29, tied the knot in Costa Rica in June 2025, less than a year after getting engaged in November 2024 at Crystal Cove Cottages in Newport Beach, California.
“When Brighton dropped to a knee and asked ‘Will you marry me?,’ as he opened the box, my reaction was immediately, ‘Oh, my gosh, yes!’” Randolph told People at the time of their engagement.
One year after their wedding, Randolph reflected on the milestone moment.
“6.3.2025 🤍,” Randolph wrote via Instagram in June. “One year ago today, we had a sweet, intimate ceremony in Laguna Beach with our grandparents who weren’t able to make it to our Costa Rica wedding (and parents too!). It was such a special day that we’ll cherish forever.”
She continued, “Our wedding bands have this date engraved inside them, my bouquet was made by my mom and grandma and wrapped with a sleeve from my grandma’s wedding dress, and Brighton’s grandpa married us. The day was sunny and beautiful, ending with a little rain shower that felt like good luck. Forever one of the most special days of our lives. Happy ‘official’ one year baby. 🤍.”
Randolph and Reinhardt began dating in 2020 after several years of friendship. One year prior, Randolph appeared as a contestant on Colton Underwood’s season of The Bachelor. The pair ended the show together, without an engagement, before calling it quits in May 2020.
After their split, Us confirmed in September 2020 that Randolph had been granted a restraining order against Underwood. Randolph claimed at the time that Underwood was stalking and harassing her. The case was dropped in November 2020.
Underwood came out as gay the following year. He married husband Jordan C. Brown in May 2023 and welcomed son Bishop in September 2024 via surrogate.
