Skip to main content

Foster Mom Killed 5-Year-Old for Having Snacks in Bed, Dumped Body in Sewer Drain: Prosecutors

Pammy Maye Foster Mom Killed 5-Year-Old for Having Snacks in Bed
Pammy MayeYouTube

An Ohio woman confessed to police she suffocated her 5-year-old foster son because he had snacks in his bed at night, according to prosecutors, who said she also revealed she dumped his body in a sewer drain.

On Thursday, November 19, a judge sentenced Pammy Maye to 29 years to life in prison in the killing of Darnell Taylor in Columbus in February 2024, per CBS affiliate WBNS-TV.

“To murder a defenseless, innocent, 5-year-old child is evil, wicked, heartless, cruel and thoughtless,” the boy’s grandmother, Shanda McGee, said in court, according to the TV station. “My grandson Darnell did not deserve to be murdered.”

Maye, 51, was found guilty on November 10 of aggravated murder, three counts of tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse in connection with Darnell’s death, the Franklin County Prosecutor’s Office said in a news release.

Babysitter Sentenced for Murdering Missing Boy After She Helped With Search Efforts

Related: Babysitter Sentenced for Murdering Missing Boy After She Helped With Search

Her sentencing comes more than two years after Maye’s husband called Columbus police on Valentine’s Day in 2024, saying she murdered their foster son, according to prosecutors. Maye reportedly killed Darnell after the boy brought a granola bar and peanut butter crackers to his bed.

In a 911 call, Maye’s husband said that around 3:00 a.m., Maye entered their bedroom and revealed Darnell was dead before she fled their home in a silver Jeep Cherokee. This led her husband to quickly call 911 after he couldn’t find Darnell, prosecutors said.

Maye abandoned her Jeep, which was found about two hours later in a parking lot of the Cleveland suburb of Brooklyn, according to prosecutors.

Maye was found “wandering around” a business located in the suburb the next evening, the prosecutor’s office said in its prior release. Police responded and she was taken to a hospital, where she allegedly confessed to killing Darnell.

Maye told detectives she suffocated Darnell with a trash bag, then put his body inside trash bags and left his body inside a closet, according to prosecutors.

The morning of February 14, 2024, Maye said she put Darnell’s body in the back of her Jeep, before deciding to put him in the front seat, prosecutors said. Then she got rid of his body in a sewer drain, where police found Darnell in Franklin Township two days later.

Home Daycare Operator Sentenced to Prison After Killing Boy, 5 Months, She Called 'Fussy'

Related: Home Daycare Operator Sentenced After Killing 'Fussy' 5-Month-Old Boy

At the start of her sentencing hearing, Maye declared she wished to fire her defense attorneys, expressing they hadn’t properly defended her, and argued body camera footage and 911 audio implicating her in Darnell’s murder had been tampered with, The Columbus Dispatch reported.

One of her attorneys, Sam Shamansky, contended Maye should be held in a mental institution instead of a prison due to her mental health, per the newspaper. Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Mark Serrott acknowledged he believed Maye had mental illness, which is why he sentenced her to prison with the possibility of parole.

Before Maye learned her fate, victim impact statements written by Darnell’s family members, including the boy’s mother, Latitia Taylor, were read in court, according to the newspaper. Latitia reportedly expressed regret over a choice that resulted in her losing custody of Darnell and giving custody of him to Maye.

“I was robbed of motherhood, and Darnell was robbed of a childhood,” Latitia wrote in her statement. “Darnell will always and forever be my son.”

If you or someone you know is experiencing child abuse, call or text Child Help Hotline at 1-800-422-4453.

Read More:
Close Button for "Got a Tip" Form
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!
Please enter a name.
Please enter a valid email.
Please enter a phone number.
Please enter a message.

✕
Already have an account?