Skip to main content

Judge Orders Woman’s Release After 26 Years in Prison, Tosses Her Murder Conviction

Woman Who Spent 27 Years in Prison Has Murder Conviction Vacated by Judge
GABRIEL BOUYS/AFP via Getty Images

A Michigan judge ordered a woman’s “immediate” release from prison and vacated her first-degree murder conviction after finding her trial attorney ineffectively represented her more than 26 years ago.

Tashiena Combs, who was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole in 2000, “is coming home after nearly 27 years in prison,” the Michigan State Appellate Defender Office announced in a Thursday, November 18, news release.

Combs, 50, was previously convicted in Oakland County in a person’s fatal shooting that occurred in 1999, per The Detroit News. She was found guilty of first-degree murder, carrying a concealed weapon and the use of a firearm during the commission of a felony.

After Combs appealed her conviction, Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Nanci J. Grant granted her motion for release from judgement and threw out her conviction, according to the state appellate defender office.

Why Was Christa Pike's Accomplice and Boyfriend Tadaryl Shipp Not Sentenced to Death After Murder?

Related: Why Was Christa Pike's BF Tadaryl Shipp Not Sentenced to Death After Murder?

“In her opinion, Judge Grant found that Combs had received ineffective assistance of counsel and suffered actual prejudice,” the office said in the release. “The court noted that Combs has already served more time than the sentencing guidelines would call for on either second-degree murder or voluntary manslaughter, and that she is entitled to immediate release.”

Combs’ trial attorney in 2000 allegedly withheld the fact that he was representing Combs’ sister in a case also related to the 1999 shooting. Attorneys representing Combs in her appeal accused her former defense attorney of also having a sexual relationship with Combs’ sister.

“That conflict shaped the defense Combs received,” the appellate defender office said.

To protect Combs’ sister, Combs’ trial attorney prevented two key witnesses, who could’ve shared testimony supporting Combs’ self-defense claim during the shooting, from taking the stand, according to her attorneys.

Texas Woman Arrested After Allegedly Murdering Her Daughter Amid Fight Over Stolen Alcohol

Related: Texas Woman Allegedly Murdered Daughter Amid Fight Over Stolen Alcohol

In the middle of the trial, he also allegedly told Combs she needed to testify, but didn’t previously prepare her to take the stand.

The Oakland County Prosecutor’s Office later discovered Combs’ trial attorney never revealed his ongoing representation of her sister or and didn’t tell Combs she had legal rights related to the conflict of interest, according to Combs’ attorneys.

“What happened in Tashiena’s case is unconscionable,” Jana Mathieu, one of Combs’ appellate attorneys, said in a statement. “Unfortunately, her case is not unique. With a legal system founded in racism, sexism, and socioeconomic oppression, it is crucial that we do not give up on people who the system has tried to throw away. It doesn’t matter whether the case is recent or decades old — when a conviction is predicated on a failure of the system, there is a way to dismantle it.”

Read More:
Close Button for "Got a Tip" Form
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!
Please enter a name.
Please enter a valid email.
Please enter a phone number.
Please enter a message.

✕
Already have an account?