Skip to main content

What Was Susan Smith’s Sentence? Inside Her Murder Case After She Was Denied Parole for 2nd Time

What Was Susan Smith’s Sentence? Inside Her Murder Case After She Was Denied Parole for 2nd Time
South Carolina Department of Corrections

Susan Smith was unanimously denied parole 30 years after she admitted to drowning her two young sons in a South Carolina lake, bringing fresh attention to one of the most notorious crimes of the 1990s and the life sentence she is still serving.

Smith appeared virtually at her parole hearing on November 19, 2026, where she asked the board to grant her release. A forensic psychiatrist, a prison guard and two of her brothers spoke on her behalf, while her ex-husband, David Smith, urged the board to keep her behind bars.

Keep scrolling for more details on Susan’s sentence following her hearing:

Child Killer Susan Smith Serving Life Sentence Has Second Parole Hearing Scheduled for This Fall

Related: SC Child Killer Susan Smith Has 2nd Parole Hearing Scheduled for This Fall

Inside Susan Smith’s Prison Sentence

In 1994, Susan rolled her car into John D. Long Lake in South Carolina with her two sons, Michael and Alex, strapped inside. The boys — 3 years old and 14 months old at the time — drowned.

Susan initially told authorities that her children had been taken during a carjacking, a story that captured national attention as she publicly pleaded for their safe return. Nine days later, she confessed that she had killed them.

One year after the crime, Susan was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years. That sentence set the timeline for the parole hearings she has faced over the past two years, both of which have ended with the board voting unanimously to keep her incarcerated.

Susan Smith Denied Parole for the 2nd Time

The November 2026 hearing marked the second time Susan was eligible for release. She first became eligible in November 2024, when the board also voted unanimously to keep her in custody. At that initial hearing, only six of the 471 letters and emails the parole board received supported her release.

David told the board at the second hearing that granting his ex-wife parole would be “a huge injustice” to Michael and Alex.

The unanimous denial means Susan will remain behind bars, though she is eligible to seek parole again in the future under the terms of her original sentence.

David Smith’s Argument Against Susan Smith’s Release

Before the latest hearing, David spoke to Us about his plans to oppose Susan’s bid for freedom. He said he and his wife, Tiffany Smith, intended to attend the hearing and press the board to deny her release.

“I’m not looking forward to speaking again and going through that, but I do plan on being there every time,” David told Us ahead of the hearing. He said he planned to “speak from the heart” and keep the focus on his late sons.

“I’m going to tell them, don’t keep her incarcerated because of what she’s done to me. Keep her incarcerated because of what she did to Michael and Alex,” David said. “Her behavior through the years [in prison] has shown it’s still all about Susan. In my heart of hearts, I don’t think she’s remorseful, and I don’t think she really cares what she did.”

David’s first parole hearing appearance in 2024 included emotional pleas from Tiffany and the couple’s daughter, Savannah. He said he plans to continue showing up whenever Susan comes before the board.

What Was Alex Murdaugh Sentence Before His Murder Convictions Were Overturned

Related: What Was Alex Murdaugh's Sentence Before His Convictions Were Overturned?

David Smith on His Last Conversation With Susan Smith

David told Us that he last spoke directly to his ex-wife one month after her confession. He said corrections officials permitted him to speak with her for about an hour, and he described her response as detached and brief.

“They let me talk to her for about an hour, and even then, she very nonchalantly said, ‘I’m sorry. I don’t know why I did it,’” David shared. “And that was it. I’m not exaggerating or downplaying. That’s the way she put it.”

David said the exchange has shaped his view of Susan’s capacity for remorse in the three decades since. He pointed to it as one of the reasons he does not believe she is prepared to reenter society, even after serving 30 years.

Inside Susan Smith’s Disciplinary Record Behind Bars

While incarcerated, Susan has been disciplined for numerous violations ranging from drug offenses to sexual relations with prison staff. Those infractions have become a central part of the argument her ex-husband and his family bring to parole officials.

Tiffany questioned whether Susan should be eligible to apply for parole at all given the severity of the original crime.

When Is Ruby Franke’s Parole Hearing? Updates as She Serves Time in Prison for Child Abuse

Related: When Is Ruby Franke’s Parole Hearing After She Pleaded Guilty to Child Abuse?

“Sometimes it feels like she’s not being punished enough,” Tiffany told Us. “When she was sentenced, she was given life. We think the life sentence should mean her whole life. You took two precious little lives, yet you’re going to get another chance at life after 30 years — or 32 now. They didn’t get that chance. It’s very unfair.”

Tiffany added that she is “appalled” at what she described as Susan’s lack of accountability over the past three decades.

“When Susan spoke at the last parole hearing, it was all about her, and she had those same crocodile tears that she did in the nine days when she claimed that they were missing,” Tiffany shared. “She’s had 32 years — if she wanted to write a letter to [David] to let him know how sorry she was or anything, [she could have], but no, she’s not even done that.”

This story was compiled with the help of AI tools and edited by journalists.

Read More:
Close Button for "Got a Tip" Form
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!
Please enter a name.
Please enter a valid email.
Please enter a phone number.
Please enter a message.

✕
Already have an account?