Ali Fedotowsky: Which of My Men Should Have Been New Bachelor

 C Flanigan/FilmMagic

Ali Fedotowsky will be tuning in when Brad Womack returns as The Bachelor early next year. But the former Bachelorette admits she had other men in mind for the show's 14th season.

"Roberto [Martinez] and I were sort of hoping for Jonathan or someone from our season [of Bachelorette], just because we would have a personal connection," Fedotowsky, 26, told Thursday at the 7 For All Mankind Warehouse Sale at L.A.'s Convention Center.

The reality star (now engaged to Martinez) has a soft spot for controversial Jonathan "Weatherman" Novack, who vied for her final rose earlier this year. "I would've really liked to see Jonathan," she said, laughing. "Just because it would've been so entertaining! I feel like people would pick on him, and I don't want him to have to deal with that."

Other picks? Runner-up Chris Lambton, who was offered the opportunity but turned it down, "would have made a great bachelor," she told Us. "But I totally respect his reasons for not [doing the show]. I respect him a lot for his decision."

"Craig R. would have been great," Fedotowsky added, "and so would Kirk. Kirk has been through so much in his life, and has such a positive outlook on life. He would've appreciated and just cherished every moment of the experience — which is hard to do sometimes when you are going off of three hours asleep and haven't eaten in 12 hours, and you're on a date."

Fedotowsky hasn't met Womack, 37, but sympathizes with some of the flack he's gotten for returning to the show after not picking anyone the first time around.

"I know what kind of media backlash that can have," she told Us. "When people thought I didn't pick anybody, everyone was so angry with me. I remember thinking, 'What if I didn't find anyone? What if Roberto wasn't here?' So I respect that."

Another thing she respects? Womack's stamina! "Bless his heart for actually wanting to do this a second time, because it's hard!" She added, laughing: "If I had to do it all over again…to find Roberto? Yes. But would I want to? Probably not. It's hard, so good luck buddy!"

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Want stories like these delivered straight to your phone? Download the Us Weekly iPhone app now!