On Monday's all-new episode of The Bachelor, a desperate Courtney Robertson pulled Ben Flajnik aside for some one-on-one time during a date in Switzerland to come clean about her relationship with the other women in hopes that her honesty would earn her bonus points in the end stages of the competition.
"I tried really hard to be nice with [the other women], but that's a really unique situation for me," she said. "I'd say something and they'd jump on me. I had my guard up."
Little does Flajnik know, however, Robertson said more than a few hurtful things to her fellow cast members.
When returning to Scottsdale, Ariz., to film the February 20 hometown-visits episode, Robertson told family members she "had it all wrapped up" and didn't see any competition from Lindzi Cox or Nicki Sterling, whom she dubbed "Horsey" and "Fatty" respectively.
Warned multiple times by the other bachelorettes to "tread lightly" around Robertson, Flajnik appears to finally be seeing her true colors.
Indeed, on Monday's show, eliminated contestant Kacie Boguskie returned to get in one more dig about Robertson. "If you pick her, you'll get your heart broken," Boguskie matter-of-factly warned Flajnik.
Watching her scheming ways each week on TV "really bothers him," says a pal. After popping the question to Ashley Hebert on The Bachelorette last year and being rejected, "Ben once again feels like he was fooled," says his friend. "He figured that on The Bachelor, he would have more control of the situation, but he had the wool pulled over his eyes and feels like a loser again."
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!