The actress, 27, was on the show on Tuesday, January 31 to promote her new movie Fifty Shades Darker, but ended up crying with laughter while doing Mad Lib Theater.
After mulling over the silly selection of words she wanted to pick for the cue cards they’d have to read from, she was ready to perform.
The pair reenacted the scene from Fifty Shades of Grey when Anastasia Steele meets Christian Grey for the first time in his office, with hilarious results.
Rather than creating a passion-fueled flirtation, Johnson ended up wiping away tears, because she couldn’t stop laughing.
The words “pinching,” “penguins” and “sausage” were slipped into the conversation causing both the host and his guest to completely lose their composure.
Johnson even managed to squeeze “Zamboni driver” into the segment.
Check out the entire sketch in the video above.