Gia and Ali Both Want to Be the Next Bachelorette!

 ABC/CRAIG SJODIN

Call it a battle of the Bachelorettes.

Gia Allemand and Ali Fedotowsky, who appeared on the current Bachelor season, wouldn't mind headlining the female version of the ABC show.

"Yeah, I would definitely consider it," Allemand, 26, told USA Today in a press call Thursday. "It's such an amazing experience. I would love to find love and see how it is on the other end."

Fedotowsky, 25, tells E! News that "the idea of being put in another situation where I have to choose love over work is very frightening to me." But she says "it would be so exciting and wonderful."

For now, she is playing coy on rumors that she's already been offered a gig.

"I'd have a really difficult time and I'd have to have some really deep conversations to go for anyone. I don't know how good I would be because I might just be drilling everyone," she says. "We'll see if they think I could do that."

Tell Us: Who would make the better Bachelorette – Gia or Ali?

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Want stories like these delivered straight to your phone? Download the Us Weekly iPhone app now!