Lady Gaga Will Be Caught in American Horror Story Love Triangle Between Matt Bomer, Finn Wittrock

1434577878_matt-bomer-lady-gaga-finn-wittrock-zoom
Lady Gaga will be stuck in the middle of a love triangle on American Horror Story between Matt Bomer (left) and Finn Wittrock.  Imeh Akpanudosen/Getty Images; Jason Merritt/Getty Images; Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic

Look out, Taylor Kinney! Lady Gaga’s preparing for her first TV series regular role on American Horror Story: Hotel, and it looks like two sexy guests want to check in to her room. 

Show creator Ryan Murphy teased the news on Twitter on Wednesday, June 17, writing, “Finn Wittrock is checking into HOTEL. Who will Gaga choose — Finn or Matt Bomer? #AHSHotel.” 

Bomer, 37, previously announced he would be starring opposite Gaga, 29, in the show’s fifth season at the PaleyFest panel in March. Now it looks like he’ll have some competition from Wittrock, 30, who played psychotic serial killer Dandy Mott during last season’s Freak Show

Gaga herself announced both her casting and this season’s theme back in February, captioning a creepy Twitter clip, “Make your reservation now. #GagaAHSHotel.” 

In real life, the “Applause” singer is happily engaged to her longtime love, Kinney, who popped the question this past Valentine’s Day with a giant, heart-shaped diamond sparkler. 

Tell Us: Do you think Lady Gaga will pick Finn Wittrock or Matt Bomer on American Horror Story?

For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on YouTube!