After a harrowing Halloween special, Pretty Little Liars returns to ABC Family Tuesday, Jan. 8, with all new episodes.
Series stars Keegan Allen, 23, and Tyler Blackburn, 26, stopped by Us Weekly's New York City offices Jan. 2 to dish on the winter season premiere.
"A lot of the insanity that happened in the Halloween episode, it gets touched on throughout the season," said Allen, whose character, Toby Cavanaugh, was recently revealed to be part of the villainous A team. "There's a lot of secrets that happen on the train and we find out a lot more of what's tormenting the girls and pushing the girls toward their breaking point."
Blackburn — who plays Hanna Marin's boyfriend, Caleb Rivers — added, "Everybody has their own secrets on the show. I think it's sort of a reflection of life. As life goes on, everybody's dirty secrets are revealed."
The long-haired actor hinted there may be more in store for Caleb this season. "For my character, his [secrets] have been pretty tame, and I think they'll continue to be mostly stuff about his past and his family. I think there's always room for more."
Viewers aren't the only ones who can't get enough of the show's numerous twists and turns, according to Allen. "You read every script and you're like, 'Oh, my gosh! How are they going to make this work?'"
According to Allen, the best is yet to come. "The finale is absolutely insane," he told Us. "You get a lot of secrets revealed, some of which you might not want to know about."
Pretty Little Liars airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. EST on ABC Family.
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!