Beware, Challenge alum! What happens on a Challenge won't always be kept quiet! During an appearance on Watch What Happens Live Thursday, Sept. 19, MTV Real World all-stars joined together for a reunion — and then some. When a caller asked Chris 'CT' Tamburello (Real World Paris), Beth Stolarczyk (L.A.), Ruthie Alcaide (Hawaii), Paula Meronek (Key West), and Danny Roberts (New Orleans), who they hooked up with while filming the Challenge, it was Roberts' answer that caught everyone off guard!
"Can't say because he's straight and married now," the New Orleans alum revealed. The openly gay reality star (who's now married!) shocked his castmates and Bravo host Andy Cohen with his quick response. When asked by Cohen to elaborate, he pleaded the fifth and said he couldn't go into more detail.
PHOTOS: MTV VMA's wildest moments!
With some research, the pieces are slowly coming together. After Roberts revealed later in the show that fellow Challenge alum Trishelle Cannatella (Las Vegas) called him about the incident upset (because the guy in question was her then-boyfriend), Jezebel narrowed down the list to three contestants Roberts could have possibly hooked up with — Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin, Adam Larson and Steven Hill.
All four men are now married and have appeared with Cannatella on The Challenge. As for Cannatella, she denied on her Twitter account that it was Hill, but quickly deleted the comment.
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!