Which Idol Girl Should Get the Boot?

American Idol's Top 13 hit the stage for the first time Wednesday night and if you ask Us, the male contestants far outsang the ladies.

While early Idol standouts Pia Toscano and Lauren Alaina delivered solid performances, their peers didn't fare so well when asked to select any song from their personal musical idol's repertoire to perform.

Jennifer Lopez may beg to differ, but we had to side with Randy Jackson when it came to Karen Rodriguez's flat and uninspired version of Selena's "If I Could Fall in Love." "It felt like you were fighting the song," Jackson told Rodriguez, 21. "It was sleepy." Steven Tyler was also left wanting more, telling Rodriguez she could have done much better.

Haley Reinhart followed up last week's sultry Alicia Keys performance with "Blue" from LeAnn Rimes, requisite yodels included. Tyler bopped along to the tune, but, yet again, Jackson wasn't impressed, calling the 20-year-old's rendition "boring."

The Top 13 round was a tall order for Ashthon Jones, who chose "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" by Diana Ross. The judges were impressed, but from our spot on the couch, Jones, 24, failed to live up to Ross' diva status and it may cost her.

Sound off on the night's episode in the comments, and tell Us who you think should get the boot on Thursday's results show.

By Allison Corneau for UsMagazine.com. For more Channel Surfing, click here.

Which Idol Girl Should Get the Boot?

Which Idol Girl Should Get the Boot?

Karen Rodriguez
Haley Reinhart
Ashthon Jones
5975 Total Votes

For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on Youtube!