Snooki Slammed for “Train Wreck” Get-up

Even her signature spray tan can't steal the attention away from Nicole "Snooki" Polizzi's silly outfit. recently hit the streets of Manhattan to enlist the help of the city's toughest critics willing to rate the most questionable star styles.

Decked out in furry black boots, a knit scarf — the same length as her gray mini-dress — and a floppy Italian hat, the Jersey Shore star's style didn't exactly have fans fist-pumping.

While one passerby said the reality star looked like "an Italian mess," when she saw the 22-year-old toting an Italian flag, another sniped that "she's just a train wreck."

Also on the chopping block? The City's Whitney Port, 25, whose Moschino dress at the MuchMusic Video Awards had one critic saying it "reminds me of a fruit basket."

But the biggest complaint about the fashion designer's frock was the clashing patterns. "She's got a few different styles going on there," one critic tells Us. Adds another: "She doesn't know what design she likes. It looks like apples at the top."

Agree or disagree? Watch the video now (above)!

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Want stories like these delivered straight to your phone? Download the Us Weekly iPhone app now!