What could go wrong with a harmless game of “Never Have I Ever"? If you ask Hilary Duff, a lot! The cast of Younger got together for a fun round of the popular game, answering questions about farting in public and eating food off the floor. But things got really interesting when the stars were asked whether they’ve ever had sex in public. 

“We shouldn’t have to be answering these things!” a sheepish Duff, 28, says in a clip as she turns her paddle to admit that, yes, she has had sex in a public place. “I have too. I don’t want to tell people this!”

Duff’s costars Sutton Foster, Debi Mazar, Miriam Shor, Nico Tortorella, Molly Bernard and Peter Hermann all give their answers, and then tease the bashful mother of son Luca.

“I’ve never had sex before!” the Disney Channel alum quips, changing her answer to “No.”

“You have a child!” Tortorella declares.

“It was immaculate conception!” Duff insists.

Meanwhile, Foster can’t decide which answer is the right answer. Watch the funny clips to see the TV Land costars goof off!

Younger airs on TV Land on Wednesdays at 10 p.m. EST. 

Can't get enough of Us? Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter packed with the latest celeb news, hot pics and more!