Update: Jesse James' Alleged Mistress: What She Looked Like in High School

Celebrity News March 22, 2010 AT 10:21AM
Jesse James' Alleged Mistress: What She Looked Like in High School Credit: Splash News Online Jesse James' Alleged Mistress: What She Looked Like in High School Credit: Flynet

My, how she's changed.

At age 15 (the same year she claims she got her first tattoo), Michelle McGee -- Jesse James' alleged mistress -- was a fresh-faced student at North High School in Eastlake, Ohio.

PHOTOS: Jesse James alleged mistress

Not only was she an Honors student, she also was on the soccer team, a cheerleader and a talented track and field student. A profile in her yearbook lists her as being involved in library and guidance groups as well.

By 18, McGee (who says she was raised Amish) changed her look, going from curly hair to an alternative short blonde hairstyle. She also sported a stud in her eyebrow.

PHOTOS: Famous Hollywood homewreckers

She graduated in 1996 and fled to the West Coast, where she went on to model for tattoo magazines and adult Web sites. She now works at the Pure Platinum Strip Club in San Diego, Calif. (Her nickname: "Bombshell.")

"She's very comfortable with who she is and what she believes in," her Pure Platinum Strip Club coworker Mary Guzman tells Us.

Tell Us What You Think

81
Comment by signing in with or creating your Facebook account by clicking below.
  • May 19, 2010 - 3:21pm John Linc

    "At age 15 (the same year she claims she got her first tattoo" 9th grade Michelle never even thought of a tattoo let alone got one. She would have showed it off like there was no tomorrow. Shes was a quiet GEEK so to speak. Actually I think she was at her most normal time of life in the 9th grade. No Tattoo I would put a hundred dollar bill down on that one.

  • May 19, 2010 - 1:49pm John Linc

    Denny WAS NOT AMISH LOL! He owned a hair sylon called Denny and Denises Hair Styling. Everytime I went there, there was small pic of Michelle in Dennys mirror. He didn't like me asking about her because I was party nut youth back than. He is not in anyway Amish. That man is lying. Actually, all my bothers, and my Dad went there. I don't know if my Mom went there. My Dad knows Denny personally.

  • May 19, 2010 - 1:42pm John Linc

    Yep that's the Michelle McGee I remember. She was in some of my classes in high school. Her Dad Denny used to cut my hair for years lol. She used to brag a little about having to see a psychiatrist. I would talk to her often as she sat right next to me in Math. As that year went on I remember she became more and more anti-social. Started wearing black and stuff. We were Juniors, or Seniors? She became very B**tchy and mean.

  • May 15, 2010 - 2:54pm Angie

    I go to North Highschool O:

  • April 06, 2010 - 6:20am S

    she is bald

  • April 05, 2010 - 10:51am kkbbei

    If this woman was raised Amish, she would have been shunned. Further, the Amish are educated in one-room school houses and not past the 8th grade. Also, what's good Amish fellow doing on the Net, Denny? You might pray the Ordnung doesn't learn of it, lest you be shunned also. What a crock!

  • April 05, 2010 - 10:23am BIE

    You were better with your former look but now you just disgust that I wanna PUKE.

  • April 01, 2010 - 4:38am Boopster

    ANYONE CAN MAKE A MISTAKE BUT IF YOU ARE NOT DONE "soaking ur oaks"THAN BE ALONE DON'T INVOLVE A THIRD,FOURTH,FIFTH ETC.. PARTY,LEOPARDS never CHANGES ITS SPOTS:)

  • March 31, 2010 - 2:52pm Dawn

    The comment below claiming to be from her father is a lie, and an obvious one. Just saying for those who didn't know: she claims that she no longer talks to her parents as they are conservative & disowned her. Nice try though. Next time, don't pose as an Amish person because they don't browse celebrity magazine websites! One more thing, this girl claims she's 24- yet she graduated in 1996? She would have only been in grade school in '96 if she was only 24 years old. I'm turning 30 this year and graduated class of 1999 so she definitely is in her 30's too. What a bad liar!

  • March 31, 2010 - 10:56am Victoria

    Woof! lol I didn't Amish people could attend PUBLIC school and take PICTURES!! Or use the internet Mr. Denny Mcgee!! She must think the world is DUMB! She is obviously nothing but a LIAR!!

  • March 30, 2010 - 6:38pm Diane

    lololol ooooooo-k...you're her Amish father, huh? what the hell you doing on the internet??? maybe took the horse and buggy to the library? you broke the Amish rules to surf celebrity gossip sites?? lol oh..and her school picture..since when do Amish take school pictures?? or pictures at all?? too funny.

  • March 30, 2010 - 6:04pm Luke Sassypants

    Denny, as a father I understand how you feel about your daughter. It appears that she is rebelling and although it was probably not how she was raised it is very common to see people go in the opposite direction once they get away from the confines of home. The problem with Michelle is that she is now hurting others with her behavior and that is not excusable and does not give her the right to be left alone anymore. All we know is what we see, and her ex husband said things, whether true or not that influences how she is viewed. If she didn't want the spotlight on her, she should have not gone public. Her video postings give everyone the only glimpse into her life that many will ever see. No ones fault but hers.

  • March 30, 2010 - 2:57pm Mr. Denny Mcgee

    lease leave my daughter ALONE!!!! Understand people that whatever it takes, I love my daughter and will defend her with my life. We brought her up as a conservative Amish without TV, internet, newspapers or magazines. She does NOT know anything about the outside world. When she left us, she met a man who she thought was true and honest but later on betrayed her. She's just a troubled soul crying for justice and understanding. Judge NOT that ye be not judged. He who does NOT sin cast the first stone.

  • March 30, 2010 - 2:23pm Trina

    Bonnie at 11:06- You are too funny telling people who post on here to get a life and find something better to do, when you are obviously on here reading their posts and posting yourself-what does that say about you? Lol ;) As for this McGee lady, I don't blame her at all. If Jesse had kept it in his pants he wouldn't be in this situation. He was the one that was married and I believe he gets 100% of the blame. He knew what he was doing.

  • March 29, 2010 - 5:07pm Bonnie

    So, a cute girl in high school turns into a tattooed freadazoid and that's what Jesse likes??? Sandra, we love you and hope you can move past this chaos and find real love.

  • March 29, 2010 - 7:29am Devonslame

    First of all, she is soo ugly. Secondly, there is no way she was raised Amish. Piece of trash.

  • March 26, 2010 - 1:02am benita

    she looks like a trash, and she is indeed a garbage!

  • March 25, 2010 - 8:23am Jenii84

    If I saw her on the street I'd throw my chips at her and tell her she ain't all that in a bag of potato chips! LOL! What a homewrecker!

  • March 24, 2010 - 10:44pm Davidsgirl

    If this chick graduated from high school in 1996 she would be 32 not 25.

  • March 24, 2010 - 3:57pm I'm not Recep's girlfriend

    Bwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha My was she funny looking. I can't believe this Bit.ch. was even a honors student. Michelle doesn't look she couldn't put two and two together. LOL LOL LOL.

ADVERTISEMENT