Her new nose may be getting rave reviews, but Vienna Girardi might want to think about giving her wardrobe a makeover.

The reality star, 25, wore a super-short print romper and sky-high platform sandals in Malibu, Calif. on August 9 where she and boyfriend Kasey Kahl hosted the Fiat beach house party.

Unfortunately, the Us Weekly Fashion Police were less than impressed with the Bachelor Pad 2 contestant's outfit choice, with one top cop remarking, "It looks like a dish towel that she threw over her shoulder and cinched at the waist."

"It doesn't even make sense," says another critic of the ensemble.

Hear what others had to say about this look, and find out the consensus on another celeb's bizarre ensemble in the video above.