See hilarious old pictures of Mariah Carey, Nicki Minaj, Keith Urban and Randy Jackson
Steven Tyler: Now
Taking part in Idol's 10th and 11th seasons, Tyler frequently offered constructive criticism, and flirted good-naturedly, with the contestants. "I'm really not one for giving insults," he told Us before his Idol stint began. "They have a voice and I don't want them not singing to their kids when they grow up."