Jorge Nunez

Puerto Rico contestant Nunez, 21 -- who sparked a debate among the judges as to if he should sing with his Spanish accent -- has earned the votes of a few famous fans: Marc Anthony and Jennifer Lopez! Ryan Seacrest revealed that he received a text message from Anthony after Nunez performed. "Please tell Jorge that Jen and I could not be prouder," the message read. "We were in tears witnessing [his] pure talent."