It is much classier to give it back...gift or not. However, these are two major trashbuckets that we are speaking of. I am a firm believer in returning wedding all contriband; I think that (money or no money) he deserves the ring back.

she doses not give back the ring she married him .. he gave her the ring before the marriage i never gave back the ring when i left my husband thats absured give back the ring hahahaha....she keeps it in my books.

Normally, I would say keep it. But they were barely married long enough to even say they were technically married!!!!! She is a disgrace to married women everywhere! She is why people think marriage is a joke nowadays. If one doesn't work for me, then I'll move onto the next guy!! We need to be more of a Christian society and then maybe marriages would last a lifetime like they're meant to!!!!!!!!

he only came out from under his trailer when he saw that she was getting serious with someone else. what a loser!! pam, keep it u deserve it just for sleeping with that ugly mug!

she should keep it

She gets the ring! If the never made it down the aisle thats a diffrent story. Do you think Marylin Monroe gave back her seven rings? she didn't

When I got rid of my ex....I took my ring off my finger, placed it back in the original box, and gave it to him. I also removed the wedding band from his finger.

Sure, the ring he gave me was valued at $2000. What's the point of keeping it?

I dont think it really matters one way or another.Its not like either one of them is hurting for cash.Though it would be nice if she gave it back to him.Why does she want a reminder of her failed relationship?Also I would have to say,its the least she can do,after the wonderfull gift Im pretty shure she gave him(hep c).Spreading disease is pretty gross.

If I knew what the exact circumstances were, I would be able to say yes or no. However I will say this...they were married, she fulfilled her part of that agreement, even if she lied during that marriage. I don't see WHY she would want it other than it is expensive, and you know, rich people seem to think that THINGS make you important and better, so, maybe she feels like a better woman by keeping it.

Well, if he had had the sense to break the engagement before entering into that marriage, then he would have the ring back. Once you are married, it is yours to keep. you have kept up the terms of the contract. Only if she had signed an agreement to return it in the event of a divorce, then she should, but in normal circumstances, no. The only reason I think she should return it is, Why would she want it? They are broken up, the marriage is over. Why keep a momento from that time? At the very least, if she iddn't want him to benefit, at least sell it!

The ring is hers...he's bitter...she should make a necklace out of it.

In the case of a broken engagement, the ring should be returned as an engagement ring represents a contract (if not given on a birthday or holiday then it is a gift and gifts do not need to be returned.) She is not obligated to return it unless it is part of their divorce settlement and she agrees to it. Kid Rock is just bitter. He needs to let go of the ring, of her and move on with his life.

If it were me I'd give it back. It's something that represents love shared between two people, I'd give it back and start fresh with my new husband.

She should give the ring back. They were only married for 3 months! I can see if you have been married to someone for years how you would keep the ring. You have earned it so to speak. But they werent tg for even a year, not even half a year. Pam should be the bigger person and just return the ring. Like she needs the money its worth anyway!

I jerk 0ff midgets for $10 and invest it in my stock portfolio!