Reminicising to Extra at the Hollywood premiere of Horrible Bosses 2 on Thursday, Nov. 20, Aniston boasted that her bare butt appeared "way" before Kardashian's. "Oh, way, yeah. I was an original," the star, 45, said.
"[Mine] was just innocent, there's nothing aggressive about that," Justin Theroux's fiancée added of her arguably tasteful nude in-bed cover, which was shot by Mark Seliger. "Sorry, Kim K.," she jokingly added after Extra called her a "pioneer."
Aniston's cheeky 1996 RS cover marked her first solo cover for the magazine. The actress had previously posed for the mag with her four Friends costars in 1995.
Kardashian, on the other hand, had already bared it all in Playboy (in 2007) prior to dropping trou for Paper mag.
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!