They may score high on the dance floor, but when it comes to playing the “Newly Engaged Game,” Dancing With the Stars pros Jenna Johnson & Val Chmerkovskiy don’t fare quite as well. The couple, who got engaged in June in Venice, Italy, took off their dancing shoes and got ready to throw down when they recently stopped by Us Weekly’s studio.

From fessing up to their pet peeves about each other to trying to figure out their favorite emojis, watch the video above to how they did when they sat down with Us for a friendly couple’s competition.
To see the dancing duo in a city near you, check out tickets at DWTStour.com.