The identity of "A" was finally revealed on the second season finale of Pretty Little Liars Monday — but that doesn't mean the girls of Rosewood are safe.
The cast of the hit ABC Family series — Lucy Hale, 22, Ashley Benson, 22, Shay Mitchell, 24, Troian Bellisario, 26, Ian Harding, 25, Drew Van Acker, 25, Keegan Allen, 22, and Tyler Blackburn, 25 — reflect on their favorite scenes with their longtime tormentor in the video (above).
In episode 14, "Through Many Dangers, Toils and Snares," Mitchell's character Emily Fields nearly comes face-to-face with the elusive "A."
"Seeing 'A' across the greenhouse, I was kind of freaked out, to be honest with you," Mitchell recalls. "Even though I'd walked on the set and there were a million crew members around, I was still like, 'Okay, it's dark. There's this person in a hooded outfit. Oh my goodness!'"
"I love the part where Emily gets the box of cereal and it's all As. That's when I was really, really impressed with 'A,' because I thought, 'You spent months planning this one situation and it had to play out perfectly. She had to pick up that box of cereal in the lunch line.' I thought it was brilliant," Harding says. "That's when I was truly afraid of 'A.' When you do something that clever, you're dangerous."
To find out what other moments made the cast members squirm, watch the video (above). The third season of Pretty Little Liars premieres this summer on ABC Family.
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!