Skip to main content

Rachael Leigh Cook Reveals Her Biggest ‘Fear’ About Playing Twins in New Hallmark Christmas Movie (Exclusive)

Rachael Leigh Cook Reveals Her Biggest Fear About Playing Twins in New Hallmark Christmas Movie
Rachael Leigh Cook as twins Charlie and Abigail in 'Double Booked for the Holidays.'Hallmark Media

Rachael Leigh Cook has Us seeing double in her new Hallmark film, Double Booked for the Holidays — but she revealed that with double the fun came double the pressure.

“I was concerned that there wouldn’t be enough conflict within the movie because I was too far inside it,” Cook, 47, exclusively told Us of playing twin sisters Charlie and Abigail in the upcoming Christmas movie. “I was concerned that just me yapping away at myself was going to be a bad time.”

The actress joked that playing opposite herself for the majority of the movie was definitely a challenge.

“When I started to watch it, my first reaction to seeing myself in stereo was, ‘Oh no, this is way too much. I’m the worst scene partner I’ve ever had. This was a bad idea,’” Cook recalled. “Because it’s a lot. But then I was able to sort of relax into it and say, ‘OK, I think I was able to differentiate them by enough.’”

Rachael Leigh Cook Explains Initial Resistance to Working With Hallmark And Why She Is All In Now

Related: Rachael Leigh Cook Explains Her Initial 'Resistance' to Working With Hallmark

Unlike other twin-focused movies, hopeless romantic bookworm Abigail and sassy world-traveling event planner Charlie don’t have different hairstyles or dress like total opposites. So, for Cook, she had to lean into their slight quirks to make sure the audience didn’t get lost throughout the film.

“I knew that the worst thing people could feel while watching was confusion,” the She’s All That star explained. “So that was high on my priority list to avoid.”

Her worst fear, however, was that viewers would get bored with seeing Cook 24/7.

Rachael Leigh Cook Reveals Her Biggest Fear About Playing Twins in New Hallmark Christmas Movie Ball
Rachael Leigh Cook as Charlie and Abigail. Hallmark Media

“My biggest fear was just that it would seem like I was yapping at myself for an hour,” she said with a laugh.

Double Booked for the Holidays follows identical twins, Abigail and Charlie after they agree to fly to a small Welsh town called Hay-on-Wye and run the Story Shoppe, which is an Airbnb and bookshop over the holidays.

Abigail is most excited about the opportunity as she loves the town’s bestselling Winterton Chronicles, which the siblings’ late mother read to them every year.

Hallmark 2026 Countdown to Christmas Lineup A Complete Guide to Holiday Movies TV Shows

Related: ‘Tis the Season for Hallmark’s 2026 ‘Countdown to Christmas’ Lineup: A Guide

“Upon arrival, Abigail dives into setting up the bookshop’s window display with help from the friendly next-door barista, Tom (Owain Yeoman), who is also a fan of the Winterton Chronicles. Meanwhile, Charlie meets the dashing Lord Rhys (Stephen Hagan), the great-nephew of Evelyn Calon, who wrote the book series,” the logline reads.

Through “mistaken identities” and “merry mix-ups” the two sisters are in for the Christmas of a lifetime — with a possible happily ever after for both.

Rachael Leigh Cook Reveals Her Biggest Fear About Playing Twins in New Hallmark Christmas Movie Poster
Hallmark Media

Cook had to be her own scene partner majority of the time, despite having two male suitors to attend to, but she told Us it wasn’t exactly like playing herself on repeat.

In fact, she revealed she has only a little bit of one twin that matches her own personality.

Rachael Leigh Cook and Freddie Prinze Jr Reuniting for Holiday Movie

Related: Rachael Leigh Cook and Freddie Prinze Jr. Reuniting for New Christmas Movie

“I wish that I was more like Abigail because I would have read more books, and also she gets a little bit more of the gravitas in the story, and her love story gets more of that screen time,” Cook shared. “But I felt a lot more akin to the Charlie character. She just has a lot more play about her, and so I definitely had more latitude to improvise small things and just give it a little bit more sass and pizzazz.”

The Josie and the Pussycats star noted that Abigail is “much more reserved and really kept me on book” while Charlie allowed her the “freedom to stretch the characters further apart.”

Double Booked for the Holidays premieres on Hallmark Channel Sunday, November 22, at 8 p.m. ET and streams the next day on Hallmark+.

Revisit the most unforgettable highlights of the year in Us magazine’s 2026 Year in Review, a special issue showcasing the biggest moments in music, TV and movies that captivated audiences across the globe. Click here to purchase now — a great gift for your pop culture-obsessed friend (or yourself)!

In this article

Close Button for "Got a Tip" Form
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!
Please enter a name.
Please enter a valid email.
Please enter a phone number.
Please enter a message.

✕
Already have an account?