Amanda Batula went off on West Wilson for kissing another woman in front of his ex-girlfriend, her friend, Ciara Miller on Summer House — months before she started dating him, seemingly behind her BFF’s back.
“You just got too comfortable on probation,” Amanda, 34, told West, 31, on the Tuesday, April 14, episode of the hit Bravo reality series, criticizing him for making out with a random girl at their Las Vegas-themed party while Ciara, 30, literally sat right next to him.
West just shook his head after Amanda called him out in front of several other housemates.
“I’ve been trying so hard to do nothing wrong for two years. And like f***,” West told the cameras, referring to his rocky, on-and-off relationship with Ciara following their 2023 romance.
West claimed that Ciara had been “f***ing cuddling with Jesse [Solomon] in front of my face for the last two years,” so he was hoping the group could “chock this one up to, like, a drunk f*** up” on his part.
“Ciara could be f***ing dating someone right now for all I know, but I feel like I just cheated on my wife,” he confessed.
While West was battling some inner turmoil, Amanda continued to chastise him for being so blatant with his hookup.
“You guys have been making progress, so my question is: why at this small, intimate party do you decide to have this girl sitting in your lap the whole time? And like making out with her?” Amanda asked.
Kyle Cooke chimed in, defending West’s actions.
“That’s not fair!” he told Amanda, which only escalated the moment..
“Kyle, don’t make me get mad at you,” Amanda told her then-husband. “Do you want to fight with me right now? I’ll f***ing fight with you.”
Kyle, 43, tried to get Amanda to “relax,” before calling her “unreasonable” in her request for West to downplay his hookups in Ciara’s presence.
“All I’m saying is if you want to make progress in your relationship with Ciara there’s a level of respect that we have to have to live here together,” Amanda told West before she went into the house.
Amanda later revealed in a confessional that Kyle’s reaction set her off because he’s always had Ciara’s back.
“Kyle has been Ciara’s biggest advocate. Kyle has cried for Ciara,” Amanda said. “And now that I’m attacking West, you’re going to take his side?”
Ciara, for her part, was equally as frustrated after seeing West kiss a woman on the seat next to her and later on a lounge chair by the pool.
“There’s a reason why he was living on probation all this time. Now he’s back in jail,” Ciara told Amanda and Mia Calabrese of her dynamic with West after they appeared to be rebuilding their friendship throughout filming season 10 in summer 2025. “There’s a reason why I don’t trust him. He can’t be a friend to me. He doesn’t see me. … I’m not going to call out for you to notice me.
While Amanda has always taken Ciara’s side when it comes to West — and supported her during Tuesday’s episode — her outburst during season 10 is raising eyebrows after she and West confirmed in March that their platonic relationship had turned romantic. The bombshell came despite Amanda’s friendship with Ciara and just two months she and Kyle called it quits after four years of marriage.
Kyle has since spoken out about the scandal, confessing in April that he’s started to look at West’s “handsy” moments with Amanda from summer 2025 through a different lens in wake of the news.
“West seems to be the kinda guy playing multiple women at the same time,” Kyle claimed in a three-part TikTok interview. “I can imagine West is using the same charm that he’s used on every other chick [with Amanda].”
Ciara, meanwhile, has hinted at the betrayal from Amanda and West with her recent social media posts.
On Sunday, April 12, Ciara posted a collab with Sephora, which she captioned, “@sephora actually rewards loyalty,” seemingly taking a jab at the pair.
Summer House airs on Bravo Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET.
