Skip to main content

The Best Eye Makeup Removers, According to Makeup Artists

Author photo
Written by Clare Holden
Best Eye Makeup Removers

The number one piece of skincare advice given by dermatologists and makeup artists is to always take off your makeup. After a long day it can be tempting to head straight to bed but sleeping in your makeup is never a good idea. The eye area is particularly delicate, which is why it is even more important to ensure your mascara is washed away every night.

Makeup artist Caitlyn Dominic explains to us why it is such an essential step, saying “If not removed, makeup and residue can cause irritation, clogged pores, dry eyes, and even eye infections or styes. The skin around the eyes is thinner and more sensitive than the rest of the face, so gentle and thorough makeup removal is crucial to avoid these potential issues”.

To ensure you keep your eyes and skin looking bright and radiant, we have put together this curated list of the best eye makeup removers including top recommendations from makeup artists, along with tried and tested favorites.

Us Weekly aims to feature only the best products and services. We update when possible, but deals expire and prices can change.
If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more!

Finding the Best Eye Makeup Removers

There are multiple options when it comes to eye makeup removers, so it really comes down to personal preference and finding out what works for your skin type. When we spoke to makeup artist Natalie Dresher to get her top tips, she even recommended mixing products, saying, “I love double cleansing. I usually go in with an oil based cleansing balm and then go in with a water based cleanser for my second cleanse to effectively remove all eye and face makeup.”

To help ensure you are using the best products for your skin and eyes, we have put together the guide below, covering everything from ingredients to cleansing methods to help you keep your skin soft and supple.

What to Consider When Choosing the Best Eye Makeup Removers

Skin Type

As with all skincare you want to find a product that works with your skin type and not against it. Every time you use a product on your face is an opportunity to enhance its appearance. If you have dry skin go for a milky or cream remover, those with oil skin should opt for an oil-free product, while those with sensitive eyes should choose a non-comedogenic option.

Your Makeup 

How regularly and how much makeup you wear is also an important factor to consider. If you wear heavy makeup everyday, a gentle eye makeup remover or cleansing balm will help to keep your skin soft. If you only wear mascara, micellar water is a quick and easy solution, whereas if you use waterproof mascara be sure to choose a remover especially for that.

Removal Method

When removing your eye makeup, always go gently. Never tug or pull at the skin. If you are using a milk, oil, or balm massage in the product in small circular motions then rinse. If you are using a liquid, pour some on a cotton pad then place it over the eye and hold for a few seconds to soak up your eye makeup.

Follow Up Skincare

Once your face is fully rinsed and clean, you can then apply your skincare. Using an eye cream will ensure the skin around your eyes is kept plump and supple, which also helps to improve the appearance of any makeup applied over it.

Brand

Our list has the top picks from drugstores to luxury brands. Each product was chosen for its ability to successfully remove your eye makeup without causing irritation.

What are the Different Types of Eye Makeup Removers?

Milk 

Milk eye makeup removers are some of the most gentle yet effective options to take off your makeup. If you wear contacts or have sensitive eyes these are the best type of remover to go for. We recommend always double cleansing to ensure a truly thorough removal.

Balm/Oils 

Balms and oils are extremely popular for those who wear eyeshadow and liner. They work to break down the product, making it glide easily off your face and leave your skin feeling soft and conditioned.

Waterproof

For those who favor waterproof mascaras and eyeliners, this is the only type of eye makeup remover to go for. While it is essential to remove all your makeup every night, it is especially important to keep your eyes clean to remove any bacteria that may cause irritation.

1

Best Overall: CeraVe Eye Makeup Remover with Hyaluronic Acid and Ceramides

Pros

  • Hydrating formula
  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Great price

Cons

  • Some may prefer a milk remover
  • Basic packaging

This eye makeup remover from CereVe is our top choice to melt away your eye shadows and liners while also keeping the skin around your eyes soft and hydrated. Suitable for all skin types, even delicate ones, this bi-phase oil even works on tougher products such as waterproof mascara.

Infused with hyaluronic acid and essential ceramides to ensure your skin doesn't dry out, we also love how it is fragrance-free so less likely to cause irritation. The non-comedogenic formula has also been ophthalmologist-tested.

2

Best Drugstore: e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration Off Makeup Remover

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Unscented
  • Gentle formula

Cons

  • Sometimes sells out
  • Not for those looking for a cream cleanser

E.l.f is one of our favorite makeup brands, so we were delighted when they started adding skincare to their collection. Their hydrating makeup remover is our top pick from the drugstore due to its non-greasy gentle formula that cleans away eye makeup in an instant.

Unlike other cleansers that can strip away your skin’s moisture, this makeup remover delivers a trio of hydrating ingredients to ensure your lids and lashes are also taken care of. Hyaluronic acid, squalane, and niacinamide work together to keep your skin nourished and conditioned.

3

Best Budget: essence Remove Like A Boss Waterproof Eye & Face Make-Up Remover

Pros

  • Bi-phase formula
  • Affordable
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Packaging could be better
  • Slightly oilier texture

Proving that skincare doesn’t have to break the bank to be effective, this sensitive-skin friendly remover is the ideal choice for those who wear makeup everyday and tend to use up their cleansers quickly.

This pick tackles everything from black eyeliner to waterproof mascara by gently melting the products away without causing irritation. The chamomilla flower water infused formula keeps your eyes soothed and calm, so ideal for anyone who suffers from redness.

4

Best Luxury: Estée Lauder Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

Pros

  • Oil-free formula
  • Lightweight texture
  • Suitable for delicate skin

Cons

  • Slightly more expensive
  • Only comes in one size

We love investing in skincare and if you are looking for a luxurious formula to remove your eye makeup at night, this is the one to go for. Everything from the purple and gold packaging to the lightweight texture make this product feel extra special.

This oil-free remover effectively cleans away products and impurities without leaving any residue or grease and gives your skin a soft and fresh looking glow.

5

Best for Sensitive Eyes: Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water

Pros

  • No-rinse formula
  • Soothes skin
  • Balances PH

Cons

  • Some may prefer milk or oil formula
  • Not for those looking for a scented product

The skin around the eyes is one of the most delicate areas of the face which is why so many people find eye makeup removers tend to cause irritation. This micellar water from Bioderma removes makeup, pollution, dirt, and impurities without any harsh ingredients.

The no-rinse formula is both fragrance and alcohol-free and provides both an intense cleanse while also soothing and protecting the skin against external stressors.

6

Best for Waterproof Mascara: Almay Eye Makeup Remover Liquid Longwear and Waterproof

Pros

  • Both cleanses and hydrates
  • Leaves skin feeling soft
  • Fragrance-free

Cons

  • Not as widely available
  • Not everyone may need a waterproof remover

This dual-phase remover from Almay makes cleansing away even the most stubborn waterproof mascara easy. Both ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested, this product works in two stages—first to remove your eye makeup, then secondly to moisturize and hydrate your skin.

There is no need for repeatedly wiping or aggressively rubbing with this product as it has been specifically designed to swiftly break down products to make them melt off without causing irritation.

7

Best Cream: La Roche-Posay Toleriane Hydrating Gentle Face Cleanser

Pros

  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Infused with ceramides
  • Helps skin retain moisture

Cons

  • Only available in one size
  • Not everyone may like the pump dispenser

This milky-cream cleanser is the best in the business. The fragrance-free formula feels luxurious and not only does it successfully remove all your makeup, it also leaves your skin looking and feeling more supple.

More than just an eye makeup remover, this cleanser has been formulated with essential ceramides, niacinamide, and prebiotic thermal water to ensure your skin is not only left feeling clean and refreshed but also looking healthier.

8

Best Bi-Facil: Lancôme Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover

Pros

  • Oil-based cleanser
  • Non-greasy feel
  • Removes even waterproof makeup

Cons

  • Some may prefer a lighter texture
  • Slightly more expensive

Melt away your eye makeup with this popular pick from Lancome that is one of the standout products from their skincare range. Ideal for all skin types, this lightweight oil based formula makes removing your mascara a breeze as it effortlessly breaks down products, leaving your skin looking and feeling fresh and clean.

Lipid concentrate along with an emollient mix work together to gently lift products from the lids, then wash them away. This dual cleansing method also works especially well for those who wear contact lenses.

9

Best Cleansing Balm: True Botanicals Ginger Turmeric Cleansing Balm

Pros

  • Infused with skin enriching ingredients
  • Gently exfoliates
  • Light natural scent

Cons

  • Not as widely available
  • Some may prefer a liquid consistency

Cleansing balms have become an increasingly popular method to remove your makeup due to how soft they leave your skin feeling. This pick from True Botanicals feels like a mini-facial whenever you massage it into your skin and if you are looking to achieve a spa-like experience from home this is the pick for you.

This balm quickly turns into an oily once worked into the skin and the combination of turmeric and ginger along with lactic and azelaic acids give your complexion a refreshed feeling and a radiant finish.

10

Best Milk: Physicians Formula Eye Makeup Remover Coconut Milk

Pros

  • Sensitive skin friendly
  • Non-irritating formula
  • Silky texture

Cons

  • Not everyone may like the milky texture
  • Bottle sometimes dispenses too much product

Milk makeup removers are the perfect choice for those who find oils too greasy and liquids too drying. As with all Physicians Formula products, this cleansing milk has been created to be sensitive-skin friendly and without the addition of harsh ingredients.

Using the nourishing benefits of coconut milk as its base, the silky smooth feel of this cleanser gently washes away your eye makeup leaving your skin feeling conditioned.

11

Best Oil: DamDam Silk Rice Makeup-Removing Cleansing Oil

Pros

  • Packed full of antioxidants
  • Non-greasy texture
  • Fragrance-free

Cons

  • Not as widely available
  • Some may prefer a more milk texture

This ​​is our go-oil for removing eye makeup as the combo of rice bran and sunflower seed oil not only effectively melts away tough mascara, but also leaves the skin around the eyes looking tighter and more hydrated.

Despite being an oil this remover feels surprisingly lightweight and the formula is gentle enough to use on the eyes without stinging. We also love that it is one of the few cleansers that contains squalane for an extra dose of moisture.

12

Best Oil-Free: Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover

Pros

  • Non-comedogenic formula
  • Fragrance-free
  • Sensitive-skin friendly

Cons

  • Basic packaging
  • Some may prefer a scented product

Oily eyelids are extremely common so if you find that your eyeshadow doesn’t last or ends up creasing—try switching to this oil-free makeup remover. This pick removes everything, even waterproof products, without feeling greasy or leaving any residue.

Both dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, the bi-phase formula of this cleanser is also suitable for delicate skin. It has even been infused with aloe vera, ginseng, and green tea for extra soothing benefits.

13

Best for Removing Eyeshadow: Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover For Lids, Lashes & Lips

Pros

  • Works on waterproof products
  • Gentle formula
  • Provides a deep cleanse

Cons

  • Needs to be rinsed
  • Larger bottle sometimes sells out

If you love a smokey eye then this is the product to ensure your lids are kept soft and conditioned in between applications. This remover gently dissolves eyeshadows, liners, and mascaras without tugging or causing irritation to the skin.

The oil-free formula provides a deep clean to your skin to keep your pores clear and your base looking fresh.

14

Best for Contact Lens Wearers: Neutrogena Oil-Free Liquid Eye Makeup Remover

Pros

  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • Doesn’t tug at skin
  • Great price

Cons

  • Some may prefer a milk or oil cleanser
  • Bottle doesn’t come sealed

If you wear contacts and find some makeup removers tend to leave your vision blurry due to leftover product on the lens or cause your eyes to sting, then it’s worth trying this pick from Neutrogena.

The non-greasy residue-free formula cleans away products swiftly, while also delivering your skin with a calming dose of aloe vera and cucumber extract to soothe your eye area and reduce redness.

15

Best K Beauty: Innisfree Hydrating Green Tea Amino Acid Cleansing Oil

Pros

  • Lightweight feel
  • Alcohol-free
  • Non-stripping formula

Cons

  • May not be suitable for oily skin
  • Not everyone may like the pump dispenser

Wash away makeup with this silky-feel cleansing oil from Korean beauty brand Innisfree. The formula reads like a dream for skincare lovers as it is packed full of nourishing and hydrating ingredients.

Green tea water, amino acids, along with five botanical oils work together to cleanse your eyes and face thoroughly while simultaneously infusing it with moisture and antioxidants to give your complexion a fresh and radiant glow.

People Also Ask

  • Q: What is the best thing to remove eye makeup with?

    A:Cleansing milk, oils, or balms are all considered effective ways to remove your eye makeup. For more stubborn products a waterproof makeup remover is the best choice.

  • Q: What is the best eye makeup remover for irritated eyes?

    A:A non-comedogenic eye makeup remover on a cotton ball placed gently on the eye then rinsed with warm water is the method least likely to cause further irritation to your eye area.

  • Q: How much should I spend on an eye makeup remover?

    A:Decide on a budget, then go back over our list to find a product that fits within your price range. All our picks were chosen for how well they worked to both remove eye makeup and take care of your skin.

Why trust Us

At Us Weekly, we aim to inform readers to make smart purchasing decisions, saving you both time and money. Our editors are obsessed with finding products in a variety of categories from fashion and beauty, to home and fitness.

We try various products, so we can recommend our favorites, and we also summarize feedback and data from other customers. Data, like product reviews and ratings, helps us recommend the best product choices for individual price points and needs.

On top of that, we highlight unique product features for special use cases, ingredients preferences, and more. We strive to make sure you are discovering new products that can make your life easier, while keeping you up to date with the best product choices for types of items you already know and love.

Author photo

By Clare Holden

Beauty and style writer Clare has been a fan of makeup and fashion ever since she was a child. While studying for her degree in Journalism and Communications, Clare worked part-time on cosmetic counters. After graduating she went back and trained as a makeup artist after falling in love with beauty and skincare. She now splits her time between writing about all things makeup and running her own womenswear brand White Night.
Close Button for "Got a Tip" Form
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!
Please enter a name.
Please enter a valid email.
Please enter a phone number.
Please enter a message.

Already have an account?