Jennifer Aniston vs. Angelina Jolie: Compare Their Engagement Rings!

Jennifer Aniston and Angelina Jolie Jason Thomas/FilmMagic; INFphoto.com

Jennifer Aniston and Angelina Jolie are both rocking out in 2012!

In Santa Fe, New Mexico on Saturday, Aniston, 43, finally offered a glimpse of her huge engagement ring from Justin Theroux, who proposed back in August.

"It looks like a radiant cut center diamond, approximately 8 carats," jewelry designer Peter Meksian from Michael M. tells Us Weekly of the We're the Millers star's new bauble. And it appears that sexy screenwriter-actor Theroux, 41, didn't spare any expense for his love of a year and a half. Says Meksian: ""Estimated price tag for a top quality diamond of this size: $500,000."

Aniston's first husband Brad Pitt, meanwhile, proposed to longtime love Jolie, 37, this past spring with a stunner he helped design with jeweler Robert Procop: a tablet-shaped diamond engagement ring estimated at a 16 carats and also worth an estimated $500,000.

Pitt, 48, proposed with all six of their kids present. "Angelina cried and smiled," a source told Us Weekly. "Everyone hugged once she put [the ring] on. She went around and showed it to each of the kids."

Aniston was similarly weepy when Theroux popped the question in NYC over the summer. "Jen cried," a confidante told Us Weekly, adding that Theroux's proposal was "simple."

Tell Us: Whose engagement ring do you prefer?

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Want stories like these delivered straight to your phone? Download the Us Weekly iPhone app now!