Poll: Men Find Kristin Cavallari Hotter Than Heidi Montag

Celebrity Body April 27, 2010 AT 10:29AM
Poll: Men Find Kristin Cavallari Hotter Than Heidi Montag Credit: Denise Truscello/WireImage.com

Kristin Cavallari vs. Heidi Montag: Who has the better bikini bod?

In an UsMagazine.com and AskMen.com poll, 91 percent of 22,000 readers voted for Cavallari, 23, who bared her natural curves in Las Vegas over the weekend. (Montag, who underwent 10 plastic surgeries in one day last November, showed off her bod publicly for the first time two weeks ago.)

AskMen.com: How to tell if they're real or fake!

Us commenter Jeff says, "Heidi looks so unbelievably fake, like a cartoon... Jessica Rabbit or something. Before her surgeries, Heidi probably would have won this poll. She looked better in Playboy a few months back than she does now."

Us PHOTOS: See what Heidi -- and the other Hills stars -- looked like before surgery

Some 97 percent of readers prefer "real" bodies rather than surgically enhanced.

Says AskMen.com commenter Chris B, "Real breasts beat out fake any day. They have more appeal and feel much better. Women shouldn't have to change themselves to make some men happier."

Us PHOTOS: Do these stars look better before or after their boob jobs?

TheOne prefers "fake breasts on every girl" -- but in moderation. "They just look better, but that doesn't mean go overboard and get Fs! The key is to look balanced." Montag, 23, is a size "E" or "F" and cannot undergo any more surgery.

AskMen.com: Five fun facts about boobs

Not So Much says, "I actually thought Heidi looked good after her first boob job [in 2007], and it's a matter of self confidence, so why not? But her F-cup upgrade is just to outrageous-looking. I can't believe a doctor would perform such an ultimately damaging surgery!"

Greg F. thought Kate Hudson's recent implants "make her more womanly, but Heidi, on the other hand, doesn't even look human." Pointing out that she's said she can't jog because of the pain and can hardly chew a burger, he questions whether "she can even have sex... I think this is the closest I will ever come to feeling sorry for Spencer Pratt."

AskMen.com: How men have "brainwashed" women

Tell Us What You Think

49
Comment by signing in with or creating your Facebook account by clicking below.
  • May 10, 2010 - 3:09am mike

    please is anyone can tell me more about this girl. is she live in the USA? WHERE? sheyla hershey. she's hot. where can i buy her magazines? i saw her videos on youtube is she still with the insider and when her show is airing? please get back to me who knows more about her.. I'm a big fan.... give a website... please

  • May 10, 2010 - 3:03am tony

    Has anyone seen sheyla hershey brasilian playboy yet.. that is what real breast and body is... is a breath take away.... I'M A HUGE FAN OF SHEYLA HERSHEY I HAVE NO IDEA WHY ISN'T SHE IN THESE MAGAZINES. SHES SO HOT STUFFS...BIG BUTT BIG BOOBS.. GOSH BLOOD HELL..SHE'S HOT../. GOOGLE HER.. SHEYLA HERSHEY.NET

  • May 10, 2010 - 2:57am mark

    DIVA NO ONE CAN COMPARE SHEYLA HERSHEY... WHEN COMES ABOUT BREAST... SHEYLA HERSHEY.. SHES IS A DIVA.. HEIDI.. YOURE NOTHING YOU CAN'T COMPARE YOUR SELF TO MISS DIVA TRIPLE K. GO BACK TO THE HILL SWEET.. YOUR BODY CAN'T TAKE SO MUCH...-( SORRY

  • May 10, 2010 - 2:53am mary

    I google this girl Sheyla Hershey and I also Saw her while back on the insider reality show.. you go girl.. man she is hot and crazy funny.. these 2 above, is nothing more than just skinny bone and just want attention and copy what sheyla did... she came out with big breast and everyone want copy her story..lol funny .boobs fight...you go sheyla../ you are my hero...

  • May 10, 2010 - 2:47am derek

    gosh both don't get any closer to Sheyla Hershey. shes hot as hell.... that is an example of boobssss.....shes hotttt baby....

  • May 09, 2010 - 4:50pm honestly

    Heidi's face looked a lot better before surgery, but her body looks great now. If you put her breasts on Kristin's body then I would definitely vote for her.

  • May 05, 2010 - 8:18pm Jess

    Kristin is a b*t*h..... hated her on Laguna Beach.. Hate her on The Hills... Heidi... well when she stopped talking to lauren.. that mader her look stupid.. the work shes had done to her body.. Ewwww, but if your Insecure what more can you do... if she likes her body theres nothing we can do about it...

  • April 30, 2010 - 4:26pm marie72

    Poor Heidi she looks like about 35 years old.I guess she wants to be the next Pamela Anderson-her age right now.

  • April 29, 2010 - 10:25am Melissa Herrington

    What Heidi has done goes beyond crazy. I agree that the only buisness you'll see her in is porn. She looks so beyond fake and i dont even mean the body portion that face of hers is almost manly. Men like to see the softness of a womans face not a stone face. Its horrible. Dont get me wrong i may want a tummy tuck and a SLIGHT boob job but hell i'd be happy with a small C. She can't be right up in the head.

  • April 28, 2010 - 5:52pm lala

    i don't like either of them but Kristin is obviously a lot prettier and NATURAL.

  • April 28, 2010 - 12:58pm Be real!

    I know Heidi want to be a movie star but it looks like she might have to do porn to make it now. Poor girl

  • April 28, 2010 - 9:38am Casi

    Hedi Montag had one of the most extradinary unique looks. it is not that Kristin was ever pertier its that the plastic surgen committed what i think is a crime. Its as if her beauty was stolen. If I chose a Plastic Surgeon for myself I would not consult with him. Her face is destroyed hopefully she will take the fat injections out or ove rtime they will flatten because her eyes were comparable to the Holy Grail and now they are hidden behind the injections in her cheeks. We luv You Heidi ...please get away from Spencer!!!! xoxoxoxo

  • April 28, 2010 - 1:46am jen

    please stop writing about these vapid nobodies.

  • April 27, 2010 - 10:08pm Paloma

    Shocking!!!

  • April 27, 2010 - 8:56pm Gigi

    Well, of course they do. Heidi looks like a blow up doll. She looks like a cartoon.

  • April 27, 2010 - 7:54pm s.d.

    I would c u m so freaking hard inside Kristin. She's a hottie. Yummy!

  • April 27, 2010 - 6:57pm Jay

    Hope Heidi happens to read this article, she says she reads all this stuff. Hope she now realizes what a horrid joke she looks like now. The poll proves it, especially what men think. The girl looks like a hideous FREAK. She could never drown, those HUGE floatation devices on her chest wouldn't let her, that's the ONLY upside to her freak appearance.

  • April 27, 2010 - 6:50pm US Mag. is Ridiculous

    Seriously, men don't think that. How can they write that when more than half the people who go on this site are woman. I voted and am not a man. Men might find Heidi more attractive because they see something there that has no brain, just boobs. What man wouldn't go for a body with no brain?

  • April 27, 2010 - 5:21pm Tammy

    anxiously awaiting Spencer to make some sort of public announcement to vincicate Heidi and make himself look like a total ass as usual...this will be even more hilarious then this survey which is tough to beat... I LOVE that Heidi lost so badly...rub it in harder that the surgeries were completely ridiculous and un-necessary!

  • April 27, 2010 - 5:20pm Laughing as I read US...

    Kristin is so much more attractive! Heidi may think she looks like a Barbie, but it's just a creepy version of a Barbie: hard, plastic, unnatural. No one wants a blow-up doll that talks.

ADVERTISEMENT