Jennifer Aniston, Bradley Cooper Have Dinner Date

Jennifer Aniston went on a dinner date in New York City -- with another Brad!

Can you believe these stars dated?

She and Bradley Cooper had dinner Thursday night at Ristorante Il Cantinori near Washington Square Park before leaving together in the same car.

Look back at all of Aniston's loves over the years

Although there have been rumors that the He's Just Not That Into You costars are dating -- ever since he was reportedly flirting with the actress at the NYC premiere of her new flick Management -- The Hangover star found the reports "hilarious" back in May.

Check out photos from Management -- and all of Aniston's roles

"Unfortunately, it's not true," Cooper, 34, told Us at the time, adding that he was flattered. "I met her three times in my life."

Aniston, 40, is in town filming the comedy Bounty Hunter in Brooklyn.