On Wednesday, it was officially announced that Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler are judging American Idol next season.

A long list of names have been rumored over the months, from Jessica Simpson, to Shania Twain, to Diddy.

UsMagazine.com asked celebs at Us Weekly's 25 Most Stylish New Yorkers bash last week who they wanted to see at the judges' table (see pics from the party here).

Watch above for their surprising answers.