Video: Rachael Ray and Others Reveal Who They Wanted to See Judge Idol

Entertainment September 22, 2010 AT 1:20PM

On Wednesday, it was officially announced that Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler are judging American Idol next season.

A long list of names have been rumored over the months, from Jessica Simpson, to Shania Twain, to Diddy.

UsMagazine.com asked celebs at Us Weekly's 25 Most Stylish New Yorkers bash last week who they wanted to see at the judges' table (see pics from the party here).

Watch above for their surprising answers.

Tell Us What You Think

1
Comment by signing in with or creating your Facebook account by clicking below.
  • September 23, 2010 - 5:33pm Christopher Huber

    A Music producer would have been great, maybe even a Country artist too. Rappers need not apply, since this about signing and not cursing & talking.

ADVERTISEMENT