Credit: Seth Poppel/Yearbook Library

Bachelor Ben Flajnik may have his pick of a bevy of beauties these days, but in 2001, the California-born reality star was just an average guy attending Catalina Foothills High School in Tucson, Ariz.

Relocating from his hometown of Sonoma, Calif., to Arizona prior to starting high school after his dad got a new job, Flajnik, now 29, was a star soccer player who enjoyed his time in Arizona so much that he attended the University of Arizona after graduation.

As Flajnik continues his search for love on the ABC hit, only Us Weekly can show you hilarious and adorable pics from his high school days.